Book Review: The Evolution of Annabel Craig by Lisa Grunwald

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: The Evolution of Annabel Craig
Author: Lisa Grunwald
Publisher: Random House
Publication date: April 16, 2024
Length: 320 pages
Genre: Historical fiction
Source: Review copy courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley
Rating:

A young Southern woman sets out on a journey of self-discovery as the infamous 1925 Scopes Trial tests her faith and her marriage in this moving novel from the author of Time After Time and The Irresistible Henry House.

“Lisa Grunwald is a national treasure. . . . An essential American story from a master craftsman.”—Adriana Trigiani, New York Times bestselling author of The Good Left Undone

I had never questioned a miracle, witnessed a gunfight, or seen a dead body. . . . I had thought I knew exactly what I wanted and what I didn’t. Before the summer was over, all that and much more would change.

Annabel Hayes—born, baptized, and orphaned in the sleepy conservative town of Dayton, Tennessee—is thrilled to find herself falling quickly and deeply in love with George Craig, a sophisticated attorney newly arrived from Knoxville. But before the end of their first year of marriage, their lives are beset by losses. The strain on their relationship is only intensified when John T. Scopes is arrested for teaching Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution at the local high school.

Foreshadowing today’s culture wars, the trial against Scopes is a spectacle unlike any the country has seen. William Jennings Bryan—a revered Southern politician—joins the prosecution, pitting himself and his faith against the renowned defense attorney Clarence Darrow. Journalists descend in a frenzy, thrusting the town and its citizens into the national spotlight. And when George joins the team defending Scopes, Annabel begins to question both her beliefs and her vows.

As the ongoing trial divides neighbor against neighbor, it also divides the Craigs in unexpected ways. But in the midst of these conflicts—one waged in an open courtroom, the other behind closed doors—Annabel will discover that the path to her own evolution begins with the courage to think for herself.

Happy Book Birthday to this wonderful historical novel! The Evolution of Annabel Craig is the story of one woman’s personal awakening (and yes, there are references to The Awakening by Kate Chopin), set in the midst of one of the pivotal societal earthquakes of the early 20th century.

Prior to reading The Evolution of Annabel Craig, I’d had a vague familiarity with the “Scopes Monkey Trial” — I knew it centered around a battle between evolutionists and creationists. Beyond that, though, I didn’t actually know much of anything — not even where the event took place or what the name “Scopes” represented.

In this fascinating novel, Annabel Craig is the readers’ eye and ears in the town of Dayton, Tennessee as their quiet little community gets turned upside down. In 1925, the State of Tennessee passed the Butler Act, making it a criminal offense to teach evolution in public schools. The leading citizens of Dayton realize they had a potential goldmine on their hands — why not challenge the law in their own town, and reap the reward of the inevitable news coverage that would bring them tourism and an economic boom? The town leaders recruit John Scopes, a high school football coach who’d subbed for a science teacher earlier in the year. Since the standard biology textbook included a few pages on Darwin and evolution, Scopes must have taught evolution in the school. The fact that Scopes doesn’t actually remember covering evolution didn’t matter — he agrees to be the town’s test subject, and to be arrested for violating the Butler Act.

Beyond the details of the Scopes trial itself, The Evolution of Annabel Craig is truly Annabel’s story. The daughter of strawberry farmers who were very much in love, Annabel finds herself orphaned as a teen, with only her faith and the kindness of her community to sustain her. A steady churchgoer, Annabel never questions the Bible or her religion, and her belief in God is central to who she is as a person.

When Annabel marries the handsome young lawyer who sweeps her off her feet, she finds partnership and love, even though George isn’t as committed to church attendance as Annabel is, and has even been seen to doze off a time or two. Their perfect marriage begins to show strain after a disastrous court case leaves George distraught, and cracks between the couple start to grow larger.

The tensions are only exacerbated when George is offered a place on the Scopes defense team, where he’ll work alongside the illustrious Clarence Darrow, a well-known agnostic. Annabel can’t understand how George can stand against faith like this, but she also finds herself swept up in the town’s excitement, especially once a journalist — a woman! — is housed with Annabel and George, and once Annabel’s photography hobby shows promise of becoming a profession.

The trial itself is fascinating. I loved the chapters showing the developing split in Dayton, as the devout Christians and the followers of science square off and stake their claims. The arrival of expert witnesses adds another layer of interest, and I particularly enjoyed a brief scene showing Annabel in conversation with a visiting rabbi.

Beyond the historical context and the details of the trial, Annabel’s journey is wonderful, heartbreaking, and empowering. She’s devastated by the breakdown of her marriage, left at sea once she’s forced to question the absolutes she’s been raised to believe, crushed to have close friends turn on her for being on what they see as the wrong side. Through it all, Annabel starts to question her place in the world and to ponder what she truly wants, while also refusing to be cowed into abandoning the faith that’s sustained her.

Author Lisa Grunwald crafts a story that weaves together the personal and political, as we see the unfolding courtroom drama while getting to know a seemingly ordinary woman whose life is much richer and deeper than others might assume. Annabel is a wonderful character, sympathetic and strong, but also very much a flesh-and-blood, flawed person who tries to find the right way forward.

I highly recommend The Evolution of Annabel Craig. The historical details are fascinating, and so are the people — especially Annabel — at the heart of the story. Don’t miss it.

Note: Lisa Grunwald’s previous novel, Time After Time was one of my favorite books of 2020. If you haven’t read it, drop everything and grab a copy! Now I need to explore even more of her books…

15Apr2024

The Monday Check-In ~ 04/15/2024

Posted in The Monday Check-In by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

My Monday tradition, including a look back and a look ahead — what I read last week, what new books came my way, and what books are keeping me busy right now. Plus a smattering of other stuff too.

Life.

I went out — not once — but twice over the weekend! That’s pretty remarkable, considering that most weekends, my idea of fun is snuggling up with a blanket and a bowl of popcorn and catching up on Netflix. On Saturday, my husband and I went to a dance evening we usually enjoy (so much fun), and on Sunday, we went to the symphony to see Patti Lupone in concert.

Not only was the show terrific, but we also had a gorgeous view from the symphony hall balcony during intermission:

What did I read during the last week?

It’s been a slow reading week — just way too much else going on. Here’s what I did manage to finish:

The Hob’s Bargain by Patricia Briggs: Very interesting to go back and read an early book by a favorite author. My review is here.

Just for the Summer by Abby Jimenez: This author’s audiobooks are so good! I’ve now listened to her most recent three, and need to go back and try her earlier trilogy. My review is here.

Pop culture & TV:

I finished my re-watch of Bridgerton season 2, and immediately started a re-watch of Queen Charlotte. These shows make me so happy. And I’m sure anyone who cares has already seen this, but… it’s the trailer for season 3!!

I’m loving Colin and Penelope’s glow-ups…

Fresh Catch:

One new book this week (and it’s such a pretty hardcover:

What will I be reading during the coming week?

Currently in my hands:

Such a dilemma! I started the book on the left just before the weekend, and then ran out of time to get very far… which would be fine, except that the book on the right is my book group book, and our discussion is next weekend. What to do, what to do?

The Evolution of Annabel Craig by Lisa Grunwald: I was going to hit pause for a bit so I could start the other book, but now I’m hooked and don’t want to stop!

The River We Remember by William Krueger: I’m not sure I’ll be able to finish before our discussion, but I’ll give it my best shot.

Now playing via audiobook:

A Twist of Fate by Kelley Armstrong: The 2nd book in the Stitch in Time series, and it’s great so far!

Ongoing reads:

My longer-term reading commitments:

Daniel Deronda by George Eliot: My book group’s current classic read. We’re reading and discussing two chapters per week. Progress: 81%.
Damn Rebel Bitches: The Women of the ’45 by Maggie Craig: Coming soon! Over at Outlander Book Club, we’ll be starting a group read of this non-fiction book in early May. Interested? Contact me for more info!

What will you be reading this week?

So many books, so little time…

14Apr2024

Audiobook Review: Just for the Summer by Abby Jimenez

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: Just for the Summer
Author: Abby Jimenez
Narrators: Christine Lakin & Zachary Webber
Publisher: Forever
Publication date: April 2, 2024
Print length: 452 pages
Audio length: 11 hours 43 minutes
Genre: Contemporary romance
Source: Library
Rating:

Justin has a curse, and thanks to a Reddit thread, it’s now all over the internet. Every woman he dates goes on to find their soul mate the second they break up. When a woman slides into his DMs with the same problem, they come up with a plan: They’ll date each other and break up. Their curses will cancel each other’s out, and they’ll both go on to find the love of their lives. It’s a bonkers idea… and it just might work.

Emma hadn’t planned that her next assignment as a traveling nurse would be in Minnesota, but she and her best friend agree that dating Justin is too good of an opportunity to pass up, especially when they get to rent an adorable cottage on a private island on Lake Minnetonka.

It’s supposed to be a quick fling, just for the summer. But when Emma’s toxic mother shows up and Justin has to assume guardianship of his three siblings, they’re suddenly navigating a lot more than they expected–including catching real feelings for each other. What if this time Fate has actually brought the perfect pair together?

Interesting marketing — based on its Goodreads listing and the synopsis, I had no idea that Just for the Summer is not, in fact a stand-alone, but is the 3rd book in an interconnected world that includes Part of Your World and Yours Truly. Both of which I adored, by the way (you can see my reviews here and here). That said, Just for the Summer can absolutely be read on its own, but you’ll miss some of the meaning of the names, places, and relationships that factor into this compelling story.

Based on the synopsis, I was not quite prepared for how deeply serious and emotional many parts of this story are. At the outset, the tone is upbeat and humorous: Emma reads a Reddit AITA thread that is both hilarious and strikes a chord: The writer, Justin, realizes that every woman he dates goes on to find her soulmate right after they break up… and Emma has the exact same experience! She contacts Justin, and they exchange funny texts comparing their situations — and from the start, they just click.

Before long, they’re in regular contact, and have progressed to video chats and phone calls. Justin has a brilliant idea: What if they date, and cancel out each other’s curses? They’ll be guaranteed to find “the one” just as soon as they finish with one another. They even figure out the general parameters: Based on past experiences, they’ll need to go on at least four dates, text or talk every day, and kiss (more than a peck) at least once. Easy!

The complication is, Emma is a traveling nurse, and she and best friend Maddie never stay in one place for more than a few months. They take turns picking the destination for each new contract, and next up is Maddie’s pick — a summer in Hawaii. Justin is in Minnesota, and due to some family complications (more on that later), he can’t travel to date Emma. Their master plan seems like a no-go, until Emma convinces Maddie to swap Hawaii for six weeks in Minneapolis. Maddie’s more than a bit reluctant, but when Emma shows her the adorable cottage on an island in a lake — with its own boat! — where they’ll be living, she agrees, and the dating plot can move forward.

There’s much more to the story than initially meets the eye. Justin is about to assume guardianship of his three younger siblings and is soon to become a full-time parent. Emma is dealing with a lifetime of trauma due to severe neglect and abandonment by her narcissistic mother. Emma bounced in and out of foster care throughout her youth (meeting Maddie when Maddie’s parents provided Emma with the most stable and loving home she’d ever had). Emma’s trauma response has been to wall herself off and get “small”, isolating herself, refusing connection, never putting down roots, and never letting herself truly get involved emotionally with anyone but Maddie.

As Justin and Emma spend time together, their chemistry is powerful, but Emma’s unresolved trauma doesn’t allow herself to fully connect — and the fact that he has children in his life raises the stakes even higher. When Emma’s mother intrudes on her summer and her life, a series of clashes and crises ensues, and Emma’s well-being is severely challenged. Her flight instincts are never deeply buried, and this experience with her mother threatens to cause her run once again.

Just for the Summer is an absorbing, engaging read (and listen — the audiobook narrators are terrific). I was completely caught up in Emma and Justin’s stories. We get chapters narrated by each of them, often offering competing perspectives on the same events, allowing us to see the characters’ hopes, fears, joys… and understand why what they’re experiencing might not be the same for both of them.

I don’t think I was prepared for how painful Emma’s experiences would become over the course of the book. Based on the cover and synopsis, a reader could reasonably expect a romantic comedy (also, kicking through the waves at the beach, which is not a thing that ever happens). Still, expectations aside, I was thoroughly drawn into this novel and the characters’ lives, and got to the point where I almost couldn’t stand to read about one more obstacle to their happiness.

I loved the connection to the earlier books. As I mentioned, Just for the Summer could work fine as a stand-alone, but I strongly recommend reading the previous two books, which will make this one a much richer reading experience.

I did feel that the ending (happy, of course) came a little too quickly and easily, based on what we’d learned about what each character was dealing with. For Emma especially, I don’t know that I feel the timeline provided would truly allow a person in real life to progress as far as she does. Still, given the conventions of the genre, these two absolutely do need to get together, and it’s lovely when it all finally works out.

These three interconnected books all feature characters dealing with the fallout of mental health challenges, past traumas, and emotional scars. Listening to them all in such a short time period (for me, almost back to back) can be a lot. I think I might have appreciated Just for the Summer a little more if I’d had more of a break from the other books.

Still, Just for the Summer is powerful, and manages to infuse quite a lot of humorous moments into the much heavier content. I really enjoyed it, and highly recommend reading all three of these terrific books.

12Apr2024

Book Review: The Hob’s Bargain by Patricia Briggs

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: The Hob’s Bargain
Author: Patricia Briggs
Publisher: Ace Fantasy
Publication date: 2001
Length: 288 pages
Genre: Fantasy
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Beauty and The Beast

Hated and feared, magic was banished from the land. But now, freed from the spells of the wicked bloodmages, magic—both good and evil—returns. And Aren of Fallbrook feels her own power of sight strengthen and grow…

Overcome by visions of mayhem and murder, Aren vows to save her village from the ruthless raiders who have descended upon it—and killed her family. With the return of wildlings to the hills and forests, she strikes a bargain with the Hob, a magical, human-like creature imbued with the power of the mountains. But the Hob is the last of his kind. And he will exact a heavy price to defend the village—a price Aren herself must pay…

I adore the Mercy Thompson and Alpha & Omega series by Patricia Briggs — intricately plotted urban fantasy with stand-out characters, relationships, and group dynamics, high stakes, and even plenty of humor. Each new release is an event to celebrate!

I’ve always been curious about the author’s earlier works. Prior to Mercy, she’d published a few different fantasy books — a couple of duologies and a four-book series — and one stand-alone, The Hob’s Bargain. And while I’ve had The Hob’s Bargain on my shelf for years now, this week was the week when I finally decided to read it.

The book starts with a bang: Aren wakes up the morning after her wedding night feeling happy and hopeful, only to be struck by a vision. Aren has the sight, something she’s kept hidden all her life, since mages are hunted down and forced to either join the evil Bloodmages who support the land’s rulers through death magic or be executed. Aren’s vision is too late to prevent what she sees: A horde of raiders descends upon her peaceful village, and kills everyone who opposes them. Within a few short hours, Aren loses her parents, her pregnant sister, and her husband.

From here, conditions in Fallbrook get even worse. A binding that has kept the land’s natural magic under tight control is removed, and the resulting earthquake causes mountains to fall, shutting off all passages in and out of the village. The wildlings — magical creatures of the earth, forests, rivers, and mountains — begin to stir, and they’re not happy with the humans. Fallbrook is threatened by both the wildlings and the continued presence of the raiders. Once Aren reveals her sight and her access to magical gifts, she finds herself despised by many of the villagers — but also in a position where she may be the only one who can save them.

The Hob’s Bargain is an entertaining read, although the plot and characters feel a tad underbaked and rushed. At various points, I found myself confused by new developments or statements, not entirely clear how we got from point A to point B.

Still, it’s quite fun to read this early book and see seeds of themes and patterns that feature in the Mercy-verse — different types of magic and magical beings, the way humans and non-humans interact, and the dynamics between humans with powers and those without.

Overall, I’m glad to have read The Hob’s Bargain — but for those looking to experience the joys of a Patricia Briggs book, I strongly urge you to jump straight to Moon Called, the very first Mercy book. I can pretty much guarantee that once you read one, you won’t want to stop.

For a complete reference guide to all Patricia Briggs book, see here.

And enjoy these other covers for The Hob’s Bargain:

9Apr2024

Top Ten Tuesday: Backlist Books to Read

Posted in Top Ten Tuesday by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Top Ten Tuesday is a meme hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl, featuring a different top 10 theme each week. This week’s is a freebie — we each pick whatever topic we feel like. One topic on my mind is Backlist Books — thinking about authors whose recent books I’ve loved, and whether they have older books I should go back and read.

Here are the authors whose backlist books I think I’d like to explore:

1. Kristin Hannah – There are just so many! I’ve read her most recent books, but have several more of her earlier books on my to-read shelf, including:

2. TJ Klune (of course!) — I love everything I’ve read so far! Here’s one I’d like to get to:

3. William Kent Krueger: I loved his stand-alones, and keep hearing that his Cork O’Connor series is a must-read.

4. Dana Stabenow: I love her Kate Shugak series, and I’m so happy to have discovered her Eye of Isis books too! Here’s a series that I haven’t read yet:

5. Abby Jimenez: Can’t wait to start this trilogy!

6. Rachel Harrison: I have one more backlist book to read, and it looks great:

7. Kelley Armstrong: I’ve loved everything of hers I’ve read so far, so I’m eager to try one (or both) of these earlier series starters (Omens is book #1 in the Cainsville series; City of the Lost is #1 in the Rockton series):

8. Jenny Colgan: Always a favorite! I’ve read almost all of her books from the last 10 years or so, but there are still a bunch of her earlier books I’ve yet to read:

9. Eva Ibbotson: I feel in love with The Secret Countess, and now I need to read ALL of these:

10. Katherine Center: Ever since How To Walk Away, I’ve read each new book by Katherine Center as soon as I could, and now I’ve started digging into her backlist books as well. As far as I know, I just have these two yet to read:

Have you read any of my backlist picks? Where should I start?

If you wrote a freebie post this week, what topic did you choose? Please share your link!

8Apr2024

The Monday Check-In ~ 04/08/2024

Posted in The Monday Check-In by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Life.

My first week back at work after being away was just about as frenzied as you’d expect. Thank goodness weekends exist! I’ve spent the past two days enjoying the great weather, catching up around the house, and trying to squeeze in time for reading and for exercise.

What did I read during the last week?

Unfortunately, none of the three books I finished this week truly grabbed me…

Studies at the School by the Sea by Jenny Colgan: The 4th and final book in the School by the Sea series. It was nice to see the characters again, but overall, I didn’t love this book. My review is here.

The Dark Is Rising by Susan Cooper: The 2nd book in the Dark Is Rising Sequence will be the last for me (even there are three more books in the series). Maybe I’d have appreciated this book more if I had childhood memories of it — or if one of my own kids was still at an age to enjoy it. My thoughts are here.

The Garden by Clare Beams: I had to force myself to write a review of this one… just really couldn’t bring myself to care. There were some glimmers of an interesting plotline in this book about pregnancy and motherhood, but the overstuffed writing and the murkiness of the supposedly eerie elements left me feeling unengaged. My review is here.

Pop culture & TV:

I started a list of series and movies that I want to watch… and then instead of diving in to something new, I ended up starting a re-watch of Bridgerton season 2. And I’m not sorry!

Fresh Catch:

I had some Amazon credits plus a gift card… so naturally I had to spend them. Here’s what I treated myself to:

What will I be reading during the coming week?

Currently in my hands:

The Evolution of Annabel Craig by Lisa Grunwald: Started late Sunday and haven’t made much progress. I really enjoyed this author’s previous novel (Time After Time), and this one looks very interesting.

Now playing via audiobook:

Let’s hear it for great audiobooks! After my reading letdowns this week, I thought maybe I was entering a slump… but this book has snapped me out of it.

Just For the Summer by Abby Jimenez: I am loving this terrific audiobook! And what’s especially great is that I had no idea beforehand that this new book is connected to the author’s previous two (Part of Your World and Yours Truly), both of which I loved. This audiobook is making me so happy.

Ongoing reads:

Only one long-term reading commitment at the moment:

Daniel Deronda by George Eliot: My book group’s current classic read. We’re reading and discussing two chapters per week. Progress: 76%.

What will you be reading this week?

So many books, so little time…

7Apr2024

Book Review: The Garden by Clare Beams

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: The Garden
Author: Claire Beams
Publisher: Doubleday Books
Publication date: April 9, 2024
Length: 304 pages
Genre: Thriller
Source: Review copy courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley
Rating:

The discovery of a secret garden with unknown powers fuels this page-turning and psychologically thrilling tale of women desperate to become mothers and the ways the female body has always been policed and manipulated, from the award-winning author of The Illness Lesson (“A masterpiece” – Elizabeth Gilbert)

In 1948, Irene Willard, who’s had five previous miscarriages in a quest to give her beloved husband the child he desperately desires and is now pregnant again, comes to an isolated house-cum-hospital in the Berkshires, run by a husband-and-wife team of doctors who are pioneering a cure for her condition. Warily, she enlists herself in the efforts of the Doctors Hall to “rectify the maternal environment,” both physical and psychological. In the meantime, she also discovers a long-forgotten walled garden on the spacious grounds, a place imbued with its own powers and pulls. As the doctors’ plans begin to crumble, Irene and her fellow patients make a desperate bid to harness the power of the garden for themselves—and must face the incalculable risks associated with such incalculable rewards.

With shades of Shirley Jackson and Rosemary’s Baby, The Garden delves into the territory of motherhood, childbirth, the mysteries of the female body, and the ways it has always been controlled and corralled.

The pressure to produce a baby and the risks women accept in order to fulfill what they’re told is their true purpose are at the heart of this dark novel. I’m not sure that I’d call it a thriller, but I can’t really come up with another category that fits.

In a nutshell, Irene is one of many women who’ve suffered multiple miscarriages and have given up hope of becoming a mother. But when a married pair of doctors offers a supposedly new and innovative approach to increase the odds of a successful pregnancy, Irene and her husband jump at the chance to participate in their program. Newly pregnant again, Irene checks into the country home turned hospital where she’ll live for the rest of her pregnancy, following a strict regimen of rest, carefully monitored food, daily exams, psychoanalysis, and hormonal injections.

From the start, Irene doesn’t seem like a particularly good fit for the program. She’s prickly and rebellious, and immediately acts up and speaks out against the strictness of the protocols. Still, when another woman heads home after successfully delivering a healthy baby, Irene sees that there may be a reason to go along with all the rules and requirements.

But in exploring the grounds, she discovers an overgrown walled garden that seems to have some unusual properties. Before long, she and two other women begin to experiment with the power of the garden. Could this be the secret to the doctors’ success? And if not, could this offer them a last-ditch resource in case the worst happens?

Oh, where to even begin with a review of this book? I didn’t get along particularly well with it from the start, but there were enough glimmers of possibly intriguing developments yet to come that I hung in there to see it through.

First and foremost, I didn’t care for the writing style. The prose, and especially the descriptions, are overwrought and overstuffed.

She held up a second finger and turned her eyes, blue like a wrong note, on Irene alone.

Blue like a wrong note? I have no idea what that means.

What did it matter if her inner self was like these other women’s somehow — the corridors or caverns all their babies occupied, or even their minds? No one could make her own that self, whose contours were only visible in what it had killed, as her true one.

Parsing some of these sentences can be exhausting.

Beyond the writing style, the plotline about the garden, as well as visions of the house’s past inhabitants and what they show Irene, goes nowhere — or at least, not in a truly coherent way. There could be truly eerie things happening… or the women could be experiencing some sort of mass delusion. I wanted something more definite out of all of this, but didn’t get it.

Most interesting to me was the author’s afterword, in which she talks about the popular use of DES in the 1940s as a treatment for infertility and miscarriage, and how that was a piece of what inspired this book. The pressure to bear children, the emptiness of considering oneself a failure after miscarrying, the desperation to have a baby at any cost — these are all themes that resonate and are well conveyed through the characters’ thoughts and actions. The garden and its supernatural essence are superfluous — I would perhaps have been more interested in a story about the women and their medical treatments without the eerie elements.

Overall, the various plot threads and themes never quite add up to a riveting story. I was disengaged throughout, and although I was determined to see the book through to the end, I never found myself caught up in the story or dying to see what happens next. Unfortunately, my thought at the end of the book was that I probably could have done without this particular reading experience.

One quick final note: I do love the cover! Look closely at those flowers, and see the shape they form…

4Apr2024

Book Review: The Dark Is Rising (The Dark is Rising, #2) by Susan Cooper

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: The Dark Is Rising
Series: The Dark Is Rising, #2
Author: Susan Cooper
Publisher: Aladdin
Publication date: 1973
Length: 244 pages
Genre: Middle grade
Source: Library
Rating:

This night will be bad and tomorrow will be beyond imagining.

It’s Midwinter’s Eve, the day before Will’s eleventh birthday. But there is an atmosphere of fear in the familiar countryside around him. This will be a birthday like no other. Will discovers that he has the power of the Old Ones, and that he must embark on a quest to vanquish the terrifyingly evil magic of the Dark.

The second novel in Susan Cooper’s highly acclaimed Dark is Rising sequence.

And another synopsis from a different edition:

On the Midwinter Day that is his eleventh birthday, Will Stanton discovers a special gift — that he is the last of the Old Ones, immortals dedicated to keeping the world from domination by the forces of evil, the Dark. At once, he is plunged into a quest for the six magical Signs that will one day aid the Old Ones in the final battle between the Dark and the Light. And for the twelve days of Christmas, while the Dark is rising, life for Will is full of wonder, terror, and delight.

I finally got around to starting The Dark is Rising sequence this year, after having it on my to-read list for a very long time. Two books in, I’m calling it — I’m done. (At least, for now… although I suspect it’s actually forever).

This may be yet another example of wrong reader, wrong time. Perhaps if I’d read these books with my kids when they were younger, I would have had a completely different experience. But the reality is, reading this 2nd book in the series as an adult was a slog, and I never engaged with the story.

In brief — Will Stanton awakes on his 11th birthday to find out he’s a chosen one. (Hmmm, sound familiar? Keep in mind this book was originally published in 1973, well before a certain other special 11-year-old ever appeared in print). As Will learns, he’s the last of the Old Ones, a group of magically gifted people dedicated to prevent the Dark (forces of evil) from gaining power and taking over. The Old Ones represent the Light, and Will’s role is to gather six signs that together will banish the Dark, at least until it manages to try again.

As an Old One, Will can move through time. Guided by people of his village (including Merriman Lyon, the only character crossing over from the first book) — also secretly Old Ones — he uncovers the signs one by one, encountering nefarious representatives of the Dark along the way. A climactic showdown endangers his entire family and town… and Will is ultimately the one who must save them all.

Why Will? Why can’t any of the other Old Ones find the signs? It’s explained that he’s a seventh son of a seventh son, which is apparently significant, and also that he’s last of the Old Ones (but why is he the last? Don’t know). In any case, Will magically gains all the knowledge he needs to fulfill his role, and the plot centers around his quest to retrieve the signs and defeat the Dark’s attempt to rise.

Honestly? I was bored. I stuck with the book for the sake of seeing how it ended and because I was holding onto the idea of completing the five-book series… but I really had to force myself to finish, so I can’t see continuing.

Maybe it’s just a case of “been there, done that”. Maybe The Dark Is Rising sequence was new and different back when it was published… but at this point, there are plenty of magical quest and chosen one stories available in children’s books, and I didn’t feel that The Dark Is Rising offered me anything particularly unique or engaging.

I’ve heard that the series gets really good in later books, but I don’t think I’m interested enough to see for myself. As I said, this could just be a case of being the wrong reader at the wrong time.

In my review of the first book, Over Sea, Under Stone, I said that I really enjoyed the book and was happy to have read it, but that I’d probably leave it as a stand-alone read and not continue. Having now read the 2nd book, I should have stayed with my first instinct. I do think this series could be very entertaining for kids who enjoy fantasy quests, but as an adult reader, I’m out.

3Apr2024

Book Review: Studies at the School by the Sea (Maggie Adair, #4) by Jenny Colgan

Posted in Book Reviews by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Title: Studies at the School by the Sea
Series: Maggie Adair / School by the Sea
Author: Jenny Colgan
Narrator: Eilidh Beaton
Publisher: Avon
Publication date: March 26, 2024
Print length: 288 pages
Audio length: 7 hours, 19 minutes
Genre: Contemporary fiction
Source: Purchased (audiobook); E-book ARC from the publisher/NetGalley
Rating:

The long-awaited and never-before published finale in New York Times bestselling author Jenny Colgan’s delightful School by the Sea series. After all those lessons, it’s time to graduate…. Beloved literature teacher Maggie Adair loves her life at the prestigious Downey House boarding school on the gloriously sunny, windy English coast. It was there that she found her footing as a teacher and fell in love with her colleague David—the two great anchors of her life. But these days Maggie’s feeling restless, lured by the promise of a different life back in her Scottish hometown. How can you follow your heart when it seems to be taking you in two directions at once? Meanwhile, Maggie’s favorite students are abuzz at the thought of graduation and set to fly the nest to their next adventure. What will life hold for mercurial Fliss, glamorous Alice, and shy, hard-working Simone when they finally finish their studies at the school by the sea? Will Maggie stay to welcome the next class of girls, or will she too graduate to new adventures?

Oh dear. I hate to say it, but after eagerly awaiting this 4th and final book in the School by the Sea series… I sort of wish the author had left things as they were.

The original three School by the Sea books were published between 2008 and 2018, and were more recently reissued over the past few years. I’ve loved this sweet series, focusing on Scottish teacher Maggie’s adventures at a posh girls’ boarding school in Cornwall and her professional and romantic entanglements — which also introduces us to the girls of the school and other staff members, and creates it own special little world.

I was so excited for this 4th book, but sadly, I found the entire thing sort of perfunctory and unsatisfying. In Studies at the School by the Sea, Maggie returns to Downey after a summer back in Scotland with her family, feeling torn between family expectations and the new life she’s chosen for herself. She’s eager to explore her developing relationship with David, a fellow English teacher now working at an underfunded, low-performing local school.

Meanwhile, the main student characters we’ve gotten to know — Simone, Fliss, and Alice — are also back, navigating friendships and rivalries and dealing with serious stress over their upcoming GCSEs. There’s added pressure as Maggie and David create plans for shared school activities, inducing all sorts of culture and social shock among their students.

Somehow, none of the plot lines feel particularly well-developed. The girls’ dynamics get fairly short shrift, we spend no time at all with the Downey headmistress, who had some lovely story arcs in previous books, and Maggie herself seems to have undergone a major personality transplant.

Suddenly, she’s whiny and guilt-ridden, dumping an entire summer’s worth of plans to rush home to Scotland when her ex-fiance is injured — despite there being no actual purpose for her there and having no interest in picking back up with the relationship. Again and again, Maggie makes strange choices, and also seems to have lost her way professionally. A major conflict and almost-breakup occurs between her and David when they escort their students on an Outward Bound program and she feels that he’s focusing too much on the students rather than stealing romantic moments with her. Seriously?

Sigh. I adore Jenny Colgan’s books, and really enjoyed the characters of this series until now. Yes, it’s a nice idea to have a wrap-up book giving everyone a happy ending — but I just never felt that I was reading a particularly engaging story.

My recommendation? Do check out books 1 – 3… and maybe stop there! Or, at the very least, give yourself a pause before reading this one. And if you have time to kill, check out any of the author’s other terrific books. There are plenty to choose from, and so many to love!

PS – The world of British boarding schools — their traditions, grades, exams, etc — remains fairly impenetrable for an uncivilized American like me. However, I did learn two words that I’d never heard before… and I just love how they sound:

Rusticate: Basically, suspension. From Wikipedia: Whereas expulsion from a UK independent school means permanent removal from the school, rustication or suspension usually means removal from the school for a set period, for example, the remainder of the current term.
Invigilate: Supervise candidates during an examination; to watch over the administration of a test to ensure that no cheating occurs.

2Apr2024

Top Ten Tuesday: April Showers

Posted in Top Ten Tuesday by Lisa @ Bookshelf Fantasies

Top Ten Tuesday is a meme hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl, featuring a different top 10 theme each week. This week’s topic is April Showers, and the prompt is books with rain on the cover/in the title, that have rainstorms in the story, or that have anything to do with rain.

I gave it a shot — here are my rain-related books for April!

Scattered Showers by Rainbow Rowell
Rainwater by Sandra Brown
Fifty Words for Rain by Asha Lemmie
Nothing But the Rain by Naomi Salman
Sheltering Rain by Jojo Moyes
The Umbrella Academy by Gerard Way
Black Rain by Masuji Ibuse
Red Earth and Pouring Rain by Vikram Chandra
In Mercy, Rain by Seanan McGuire
A Storm of Swords by George R. R. Martin**

**Not only does the title kind of fit (hey, it has storms!), but this is also the Game of Thrones book that introduces the song “The Rains of Castamere”!

What rainy books are on your list this week? Share your links, and I’ll come check out your top 10!