Book Review: The Correspondent by Virginia Evans

Title: The Correspondent
Author: Virginia Evans
Publisher: Crown
Publication date: April 29, 2025
Length: 291 pages
Genre: Contemporary fiction
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Sybil Van Antwerp has throughout her life used letters to make sense of the world and her place in it. Most mornings, around half past ten, Sybil sits down to write letters—to her brother, to her best friend, to the president of the university who will not allow her to audit a class she desperately wants to take, to Joan Didion and Larry McMurtry to tell them what she thinks of their latest books, and to one person to whom she writes often yet never sends the letter.

Sybil expects her world to go on as it always has—a mother, grandmother, wife, divorcee, distinguished lawyer, she has lived a very full life. But when letters from someone in her past force her to examine one of the most painful periods of her life, she realizes that the letter she has been writing over the years needs to be read and that she cannot move forward until she finds it in her heart to offer forgiveness.

Filled with knowledge that only comes from a life fully lived, The Correspondent is a gem of a novel about the power of finding solace in literature and connection with people we might never meet in person. It is about the hubris of youth and the wisdom of old age, and the mistakes and acts of kindness that occur during a lifetime. Sybil Van Antwerp’s life of letters might be “a very small thing,” but she also might be one of the most memorable characters you will ever find.

The Correspondent is a lovely book about looking back at a life, understanding the past, making amends, and finding connections. It’s about a lot, actually — but isn’t life like that?

This epistolary novel takes place solely through the letters Sybil Van Antwerp writes and receives. Covering a span of ten years, we follow Sybil through her seventies, as she looks back on a life full of professional achievement, family joys and sorrows, good friends, and lots of literature. Through it all, she’s been a letter writer, sitting at her desk each day to write by hand on lovely paper. She writes to friends and family members, but also to a college dean, customer service representatives, obnoxious garden club members, and her favorite authors.

Sybil’s letters, one by one, provide readers with insight into the complicated inner life of a woman who, at first, seems like yet another somewhat cranky older woman character. But there’s so much more to discover: There’s a deep vein of grief that runs through all her letters, and as we learn, there are regrets from her past that she wishes to fix, if she can. Her family dynamics can be fraught, as we see in her often contentious relationship with her daughter, yet she displays a remarkable amount of kindness toward others in need, whether the son of a good friend with whom she corresponds throughout his difficult teen years or the high school student who reaches out for a school research project.

Themes of reconciliation and forgiveness add depth to the novel. Sybil affects others’ lives in big and small ways. A situation that seems threatening turns into an opportunity for making amends. Someone with whom Sybil interacts in a business capacity ends up having his life changed thanks to Sybil’s assistance.

And yet, we also see Sybil’s pain over a terrible loss, her ruminations on how and why her marriage ended, and her sorrow over her failures regarding her relationship with her daughter. Through her letters, Sybil communicates with others, but also investigates her own experiences. As we learn early on, Sybil has a condition that will lead to blindness, and while she doesn’t engage in self-pity, we see how deeply she fears the loss of vision, especially as a lifelong passionate reader who knows her time with books and writing may come to an end.

Lest this all sound quite dire, I must point out that The Correspondent has wonderful moments of joy and laughter as well. Sybil is courted by two very different men, and her descriptions of her experiences are sweet and funny. I loved her letters to authors. We might at first consider Sybil naive in her belief that a famous author might read her letters or remember her — but Sybil’s philosophy is to write to whomever she’s interested in communicating with, and who knows? She may actually get a response. There are several results of her letter-writing that absolutely delighted me — I won’t get into details, because these episodes are just too wonderful to spoil.

I’m so glad that I picked up The Correspondent. It’s a quick read that pulls on the heartstrings without becoming overly sentimental. There’s a deep sense of goodness here. Sybil isn’t perfect and hasn’t lived a perfect life. Through her letters, we understand her, and see what a difference one imperfect person can make.

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.orgLibro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Birthstone Book Covers: December = Turquoise!

I participated in Birthstone Books Covers for the first time in August, and now I’m hooked! Leslie at Books Are the New Black hosts this fun monthly meme — and since I love anything related to spotlighting amazing book covers, I just had to jump in.

The rules are simple:


December has three official birthstones: tanzanite, zircon, and turquoise. I’ve always loved the look of turquoise, so that’s the one I’m choosing to highlight.

Samples of turquoise jewelry:

And info about the stone itself:

Onward to the books!

My turquoise-inspired books may not be an exact match… but they capture the mood well enough for my taste!

  • The River of No Return by Bee Ridgway
  • Before the Coffee Gets Cold by Toshikazu Kawaguchi
  • Advika and the Hollywood Wives by Kirthana Ramisetti
  • The Love of My Afterlife by Kirsty Greenwood
  • Clover Hendry’s Day Off by Beth Morrey
  • Deaf Utopia by Nyle DiMarco

Do you have any favorite turquoise book covers to share?

Audiobook Review: Next Time Will Be Our Turn by Jesse Q. Sutanto

Title: Next Time Will Be Our Turn
Author: Jesse Q. Sutanto
Narrators: Emily Woo Zeller and Louisa Zhu
Publisher: Berkley
Publication date: November 11, 2025
Print length: 352 pages
Audio length: 11 hours 19 minutes
Genre: Contemporary / historical fiction
Source: Library (audiobook); ARC via NetGalley (ebook)
Rating:

Rating: 5 out of 5.

A grandmother tells her granddaughter about her twisty, often surprising, journey to who she is now in this sweeping love story by USA Today bestselling author Jesse Q. Sutanto.

Izzy Chen is dreading her family’s annual Chinese New Year celebration, where they all come together at a Michelin-starred restaurant to flaunt their status and successes in hopes to one up each other. So when her seventy-three-year-old glamorous and formidable grandmother walks in with a stunning woman on her arm and kisses her in front of everyone, it shakes Izzy to her core. She’d always considered herself the black sheep of the family for harboring similar feelings to the ones her Nainai just displayed.

Seeing herself in her teenage granddaughter’s struggles with identity and acceptance, Magnolia Chen tells Izzy her own story, of how as a teen she was sent by her Indo-Chinese parents from Jakarta to Los Angeles for her education and fell in love with someone completely forbidden to her by both culture and gender norms—Ellery, an American college student who became Magnolia’s best friend and the love of her life. Stretching across decades and continents, Magnolia’s star-crossed love story reveals how life can take unexpected turns but ultimately lead you to exactly who you’re meant to be.

If you are only familiar with Jesse Q. Sutanto through her uproariously funny Aunties and Vera Wong series (as I was), you may not be prepared for the emotional, beautiful journey that is Next Time Will Be Our Turn. This lovely book surprised me in all the best ways, and is one of the most moving books I’ve had the pleasure to read this year.

The story is framed through a sixteen-year-old Chinese-Indonesian girl’s experiences at her huge family’s Chinese New Year part in Jakarta. Izzy considers herself an outcast — she doesn’t fit it amongst her boisterous aunts, uncles, and cousins; would rather read in a corner than socialize or draw attention to herself; and knows that if anyone knew the truth about her interest in girls — in a society that’s very much rooted in traditional marriage — she’d be even more of a black sheep than she already is.

The party is shocked into silence when Izzy’s glamorous, successful businesswoman grandmother enters the party on the arm of a statuesque white woman… and proceeds to kiss her in a way that’s clearly non-platonic. Izzy is thrown for a loop, drowning in confusion and her own tumult of emotions. Later, her grandmother Magnolia meets her outside her home for a late-night walk, and proceeds to tell Izzy her own story.

And what a story it is! Magnolia takes us back to her youth when, at age 16, her parents send her to LA to join her older sister Iris at community college. Magnolia knows exactly the future that’s expected of her: Go to America, get a college degree, then return to Indonesia and marry a successful young man who’ll then be a successor to the family business (a medical practice), while Magnolia fulfills her role as a good, respectable, accomplished wife and bears lots of children. But something inside Magnolia itches at the idea of following this path. Her sister Iris certainly isn’t doing what’s expected of her — she’s loud, rebellious, impatient, and seemingly has no interest in making life easy for her little sister. She’d rather be with her American friends and pursue a career, not think about landing a good husband just to please her parents.

Everything changes for Magnolia when, on her very first day on campus, she meets Ellery — whom she describes (to Izzy’s shock) as the love of her life. Ellery is beautiful, tall, American… and warm and funny, and open to life in a way that Magnolia hasn’t seen before. The two becomes immediate friends. Magnolia doesn’t know what to make of her feelings for Ellery — back home, girls often had “girl crushes”, so that’s all this is… right? Ellery herself has a girlfriend, and what she offers Magnolia is friendship, but the intensity between the two makes it clear that there’s much more beneath the surface.

What follows is an incredibly moving story spanning decades, as Magnolia is torn — over and over again — between family expectations, societal demands, and her heart’s deepest wishes. She and Ellery go through periods of painful separation, but their deep connection is never broken. When Magnolia eventually returns to Jakarta and follows the path set out for her, she settles into a life that doesn’t fulfill her, but sees no other real options, until a reconciliation with her sister Iris brings the two closer together than they’d ever been. Iris helps Magnolia realize that she yearns for more than a life as a trophy wife, and helps her start to make her dreams come true.

As Magnolia tells her story to Izzy, she covers the years of longing and absence, the memories of Ellery that never left her, and the beautiful story of her love for Iris. Much isn’t entirely straightforward — because yes, Izzy is at first horrified to hear Magnolia describe some woman she’s never heard of as the love of her grandmother’s life. What about her grandfather? It’s complicated, to say the least.

We get interludes throughout where Izzy responds to Magnolia, but this is truly Magnolia’s story. With a well-developed narrative voice, Magnolia shares the confusion of her teens, the hopes and fears of her early adulthood, and the sometimes bitter realities of what it means to be a woman in Indonesia. As she shares her secrets, her emotions are plain to see. She’s trying to knock Izzy out of her own sense of despair and hopelessness, and it works: By telling her own story, with nothing prettied up or hidden, Magnolia shows Izzy that there are in fact other options and other ways to live a life.

I need to pause here and give a huge shout-out to the audiobook narrators, especially Emily Woo Zeller, who is simply magnificent as the voice of Magnolia. As I mentioned, this is really Magnolia’s story. The narrator accomplishes the tricky feat of making the listener feel like we really are hearing a grandmother tell her story to her granddaughter — but at the same time, her voice shifts enough while narrating Magnolia’s younger years that we also feel that we’re hearing her authentic voice at that age.

The book itself lends itself perfectly to the audiobook experience, because almost the entire narrative is a woman telling her story out loud. And at various places, she interjects with comments to Izzy — so she may be describing a romantic scene with her future husband, and will pause to tell Izzy to stop freaking out, and yes, she’ll spare her the intimate details!

I really don’t think I can say enough good things about Next Time Will Be Our Turn. Having only read this author’s comedic works, I did not expect the depth of this story or the emotional impact. I laughed throughout at Magnolia’s wry, sharp delivery — but believe me, there were so many tears too. This book left me both uplifted and heartbroken, and I loved every moment.

I know the Aunties and Vera Wong books are hugely popular — but I do hope the author continues to also write books in the spirit and feel of Next Time Will Be Our Turn.

It’s a beautiful book. Don’t miss it.

Purchase linksAmazon – Audible – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Save

Book Review: Snake-Eater by T. Kingfisher

Title: Snake-Eater
Author: T. Kingfisher
Publisher: 47North
Publication date: November 11, 2025
Length: 267 pages
Genre: Fantasy
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4 out of 5.

From New York Times bestselling and Hugo Award–winning author T. Kingfisher comes an enthralling contemporary fantasy seeped in horror about a woman trying to escape her past by moving to the remote US desert—only to find herself beholden to the wrath of a vengeful god.

With only a few dollars to her name and her beloved dog Copper by her side, Selena flees her past in the city to claim her late aunt’s house in the desert town of Quartz Creek. The scorpions and spiders are better than what she left behind.

Because in Quartz Creek, there’s a strange beauty to everything, from the landscape to new friends, and more blue sky than Selena’s ever seen. But something lurks beneath the surface. Like the desert gods and spirits lingering outside Selena’s house at night, keeping watch. Mostly benevolent, says her neighbor Grandma Billy. That doesn’t ease the prickly sense that one of them watches too closely and wants something from Selena she can’t begin to imagine. And when Selena’s search for answers leads her to journal entries that her aunt left behind, she discovers a sinister truth about her new home: It’s the haunting grounds of an ancient god known simply as “Snake-Eater,” who her late aunt made a promise to that remains unfulfilled.

Snake-Eater has taken a liking to Selena, an obsession of sorts that turns sinister. And now that Selena is the new owner of his home, he’s hell-bent on collecting everything he’s owed.

With Snake-Eater, author T. Kingfisher journeys into the realm of folk horror and fantasy, presenting one woman’s struggle to reclaim her life in a desert setting full of spirits and gods… and a bunch of terrific human (and canine) characters too.

Selena arrives in the remote desert town of Quartz Creek with just a few dollars to her name, accompanied by her very good dog Copper. She’s come in search of her aunt Amelia, but discovers upon arrival that Amelia has died the year before. The local postmaster/mayor/police officer Jenny encourages Selena to at least spend the night before deciding to leave — and since Selena can’t afford the return train ticket, and Amelia’s house is sitting empty, she agrees.

But the longer Selena stays in this odd little town in the middle of nowhere, the more settled she becomes. She insists she hasn’t decided to stay — but meanwhile, she becomes close with her nearest neighbor, Grandma Billy, learns to tend Amelia’s garden, attends the community potlucks at Father Aguirre’s church, and figures out how to earn a few bucks here and there, enough to buy Copper’s dog food. And meanwhile, the locals are warm and welcoming, and seem to want Selena to stay,

Selena leaves behind a relationship with a man who gaslit her into believing herself incapable of social interactions. Through insidious comments and continual undermining, Walter had Selena convinced that she was bad with people and could only interact by using carefully memorized scripts. As she settles into life in Quartz Creek, she comes to realize how deeply the gaslighting affected her, and painfully starts to unlearn what she’d come to believe about herself.

Quartz Creek has its own set of oddities and mysteries, especially the locals’ seemingly casual acceptance of the existence of gods and spirits. Even the Catholic priest acknowledges that places can have powerful non-human “people” who affect the lives of those who live there, for good or bad. Selena is startled by the strange figure she sees in her garden, and even more alarmed to hear Grandma Billy casually inform him that it’s a god of the squash plants. Selena is inclined to think that this must be a sign of Grandma Billy declining with age — but no; all the other folks of Quartz Creek back up Grandma Billy’s version. Gods live among them, just as humans and dogs and a stray peacock do.

Selena’s life is complicated by Snake-Eater, a god of roadrunners who appears to have transferred his obsession with Amelia to her niece Selena. And when Selena objects to the god’s attention, he gets very nasty indeed. She and her closest allies, Grandma Billy and Father Aguirre, must venture into the desert to free her from Snake-Eater if she’s to have any hope of living a good life in her newfound community.

What a great story! I adored the desert vibe. The author evokes the heat, the dirt, the plant and animal life, and makes all of this feel real and gritty. It’s easy to see why Selena would want to stay in this harsh but beautiful environment. The community itself is delightful. The people of Quartz Creek are an odd bunch, but they’re committed to their town and one another, and have figured out how to make it work. What’s more, there’s a beautiful sense of love and acceptance. Many of these people have unusual histories, but it doesn’t matter: The community comes together, again and again, and their connection makes them strong.

Selena’s story is so sad to start with. She’s a smart, likable woman whose partner undermined her to such a degree that when we first meet her, we’re tempted to believe the lie that she’s socially awkward and inept as well. Why does she practice scripts in her head? Why can’t she just talk to people? But as we see, Walter’s emotional abuse takes the form of seemingly supportive “help”, shredding Selena’s confidence through comments meant to keep her dependent on him. As Selena spends time in Quartz Creek, she’s able to slowly overcome the doubts that had been trained into her, and learn to trust herself and her new relationships. It’s a joy to see.

As always, T. Kingfisher spins a compelling story full of memorable characters, entertaining set-pieces, and fabulous writing. Snake-Eater is yet another terrific read from an author who never disappoints. Highly recommended.

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.org
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Top Ten Tuesday: Top ten books on my TBR list for winter 2025/2026

snowy10

Top Ten Tuesday is a meme hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl, featuring a different top 10 theme each week. This week’s topic is Books On My Winter 2025-2026 to-Read List.

I’m not sure how it’s winter already — I’m still not done with my fall TBR list! I ended up reading 7 of my 10 fall TBR books; of the three remaining, there are two I’m still fairly committed to reading (eventually), and one I’m not feeling especially drawn to at the moment. For my winter TBR post, I’m featuring an entirely new batch of books… but I’ll probably try to squeeze in those other two fall books down the road too!

Onward to the winter list…

I’ll have a slew of new releases and ARCs to read from about February onward, but before then, I’m going to try to focus on books I’ve been meaning to get to for a while… with maybe one or two new releases mixed in as well. I’ll save the rest of my upcoming new releases for January’s “most anticipated” TTT topic, and meanwhile…

Here are a batch of books I’m really looking forward to reading this winter:

  1. Murder at Haven’s Rock (Haven’s Rock, #1) by Kelley Armstrong: After finishing the Rockton series, I’m dying to start this spin-off!
  2. Through Gates of Garnet and Gold (Wayward Children, #11) by Seanan McGuire: Reading the newest book in this terrific series has become a favorite January tradition.
  3. Anne of a Different Island by Virginia Kantra: On a light note, a retelling of Anne of Green Gables sounds delightful.
  4. The Names by Florence Knapp: One of several 2025 releases that I just didn’t get manage to get to.
  5. These Summer Storms by Sarah MacLean: I’ve heard good things!
  6. The Correspondent by Virginia Evans: The word-of-mouth on this book is really drawing me to it.
  7. This Is a Love Story by Jessica Soffer: A book that keeps popping up on my “recommended for you” lists.
  8. The Safekeep by Yael Van Der Wouden: Sounds like an intense, immersive read.
  9. Spectacular Things by Beck Dorey-Stein: I grabbed a copy on a whim thanks to a Kindle price drop, and still haven’t started it.
  10. The Guest in Room 120 by Sara Ackerman: I’ve only read a couple of this author’s books, but I’ve been wanting to read more.

What books will be keeping you warm this winter? Share your links, and I’ll come check out your top 10!

The Monday Check-In ~ 12/15/2025

cooltext1850356879

My Monday tradition, including a look back and a look ahead — what I read last week, what new books came my way, and what books are keeping me busy right now. Plus a smattering of other stuff too.

Life.

Happy Hanukkah! We celebrated the first night last night with friends and family (and latkes!), and I have a few more Hanukkah events and small gatherings coming up this week.

Wishing joy and light to all who celebrate. Hanukkah is a time for finding light in dark times… something we really need right now.

What did I read during the last week?

The Heir Apparent by Rebecca Armitage: I loved this book! This was a spur-of-the-moment library borrow that worked out perfectly for me. My review is here.

Anne of Avenue A by Audrey Bellezza and Emily Harding: The 3rd in a series of Austen retellings, and it’s a delight! Here’s hoping the authors will continue with the remaining Austen novels. My review is here.

Kirkyards and Kindness (A Rip Through Time, #4.5) by Kelley Armstrong: A warm-hearted novella set in the world of a favorite series. My review is here.

The Nutcracker by E.T.A. Hoffman, illustrated by Maurice Sendak: I borrowed this book from the library in order to finish up one of my 2025 reading challenges. How weird to realize that I’ve never read the original story, despite having seen the ballet umpteen-million times! Now that I’ve read the book, I can see why. It’s such an odd tale, and I don’t think my kids would have enjoyed it at all as a read-aloud. This edition has Maurice Sendak’s illustrations, which are always wonderful.

Blog posts:

Beyond the usual book reviews and weekly/monthly posts, I also shared two discussion posts — one about whether reviewers have any obligation to research the books they review, and the other about Goodreads’s new approach to pre-publication reviews. If you’re interested, please check out the posts and share your thoughts!

Pop culture & TV:

I finished season 2 of A Man on the Inside on Netflix. Sweet and kind and funny, and what a great cast!

I’m on the fence about what to start next. I could dive into season 2 of The Morning Show or start one of the other AppleTV shows that I’ve had my eye on — but there are also a bunch of series on Netflix to catch up on as well. Meanwhile, I’m just waiting for my son to commit to a day to watch The Two Towers with me!

Fresh Catch:

No new books this week… and it seems like pre-holiday deals have already ended, by and large. I notice that a few of the books I’d been keeping an eye on as potential treats have higher prices now than they did at the beginning of the month!

What will I be reading during the coming week?

Currently in my hands:

Snake-Eater by T. Kingfisher: I haven’t made a ton of progress yet, but I like what I’ve read so far!

Now playing via audiobook:

Next Time Will Be Our Turn by Jesse Q. Sutanto: Before this audiobook, I’d only read this author’s Aunties and Vera Wong books — and this one is completely different from those! I’m about halfway through this terrific story, and I’m loving it so far.

Ongoing reads:

My longer-term reading commitments:

  • Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen: My book group’s current classic read. We’re reading and discussing two chapters per week. Progress: 16%. Coming up this week: Chapters 8 and 9.
  • The Return of the King by J. R. R. Tolkien: Coming soon! My book group will be continuing our LOTR reading journey starting early January.

What will you be reading this week?

So many books, so little time…

boy1

Novella review: Kirkyards & Kindness (A Rip Through Time, #4.5) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: Kirkyards & Kindness
Series: A Rip Through Time, #4.5
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: KLA Fricke Inc
Publication date: December 2, 2025
Length: 158 pages
Genre: Historical fiction / mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Mallory Mitchell and Dr. Duncan Gray take a break from investigating murder to find the most famous dog in Victorian Scotland.

A year ago, twenty-first-century detective Mallory found herself in 1869 Edinburgh, in the body of Catriona Mitchell, a housemade working for Dr. Duncan Gray, pioneer in forensic science. Shortly after she arrived, she made the unfortunate acquaintence of Catriona’s former criminal mentor, Davina, an entanglement that nearly got Mallory killed. Now she’s about to meet Davina again.

Greyfriars Bobby has disappeared. The little terrier is already a legend, and Davina has made a tidy living showing him off on graveyard tours…while picking the pockets of her guests. When the elderly dog vanishes, Davina calls in a favor from her old student. Mallory agrees to help find Bobby in return for the one thing she’s been unable to get from Davina—the mysterious Catriona’s life story.

Kirkyards & Kindness is a sweet little novella that allows readers to spend time in the world of the A Rip Through Time series — without the heavy doses of murder and mayhem that take place in the full-length novels.

Quick explanation of the series: 21st century detective Mallory ends up falling through time into Victorian Edinburgh, where she inhabits the body of a beautiful but nasty housemaid. There, she works with her employer, undertaker/scientist Duncan Gray, to solve crimes while also adapting to life in this very different era and attempting to introduce forensics to Victorian crime scenes.

In Kirkyards & Kindness, Mallory and Duncan are called upon to find a missing dog — the famous Greyfriars Bobby, beloved by locals and tourists alike. The person who hires them is an old associate of the person whose body Mallory inhabits. In exchange for finding Bobby, Mallory will finally have a chance to learn important information about Catriona’s unknown past.

The mystery has a rather jaunty tone, as Mallory and Duncan traverse Edinburgh in search of witnesses and clues. While a crime is discovered and addressed, there are also some rather sweet moments, and it all comes together with a satisfyingly happy resolution.

The novellas in the series are by necessity “extras”, in that they don’t resolve any of the central storylines of the overarching series. Mallory’s future, some abiding unresolved questions, her future with Duncan — all remain to be addressed in the main books of the series. But for reader of the A Rip Through Time books, these novellas are a nice little treat that bridges the waiting time between novels, and it’s always enjoyable to spend time with these characters and enjoy their unique predicaments.

Greyfriars Bobby was a real dog! Bobby was the beloved companion of a police constable in the 1850s. After the death of his owner, Bobby refused to leave his grave, and became a permanent, much loved resident of the Greyfriars Kirkyard. A statue in Bobby’s memory was erected in 1873, and is a popular tourist photo op in Edinburgh to this day.

For more about Greyfriars Bobby: https://www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofScotland/Greyfriars-Bobby/

Interested in this series? Here are my reviews for the previous books:
A Rip Through Time
The Poisoner’s Ring
Disturbing the Dead
Schemes & Scandals (novella)
Death at a Highland Wedding

Up next:

An Ordinary Sort of Evil (A Rip Through time, #5) — May 2026

Goodreads: New approach for pre-publication ratings

Goodreads users have long complained about those annoying 1-star or 5-star reviews for books that don’t even exist. As in… OMG, I love this author so much that as soon as a new book is announced, I’m going to go give it 5 stars! And of course, the opposite as well: This author sucks, and I know this new book will suck too, no matter what it is, so I’m sticking it with a 1-star rating!

Those of us who are long-term, regular Goodreads users have expressed frustration over this for years — and I can only imagine how disheartening it is for authors to see their upcoming new releases getting rated before their content has even been shared. These pre-release ratings — especially when ARCs aren’t even available yet — skew numbers and overall make the general rating scores less meaningful.

As of this month, Goodreads is taking action to address this issue. They’ve introduced new guidelines and controls for pre-release ratings, requiring reviewers to identify the source of the copy they’ve read before being able to save a rating. The specifics can be found here, but I’m sharing a screenshot for convenience as well:

I decided to test this out for myself! I went to the page for a not-yet-published book on my to-read shelf, and clicked on the stars underneath the book image to add a rating. Here’s what pops up next:

After clicking the Netgalley option, this is what I see:

And that’s it! Looks like I can go ahead and submit the rating at this point. (I didn’t — I didn’t actually read the book I picked, and I’m not sure it’s even available for review yet.)

Will this help fix the problem?

Well, maybe a little bit. It still relies on users’ honesty and integrity. There’s nothing to stop me from submitting this, and I’m not under the impression that the source choice is actually verified in any way. (That seems like it would be an impossible task, given the millions of people who review on Goodreads.)

I do think one little detail may help rein in those who want to rate without reading (#2 in the guidelines above):

Tell us where you received the book (ex. directly from an author, publisher or other source). Once submitted, you cannot edit or delete your book source. Your book source will be displayed on the book page when you write a review alongside your rating. 

Here’s a screenshot of what this looks like, appearing at the top of a posted review:

The source entry can’t be changed or removed — so it’s kind of like it’s going on your permanent record. Will that make people think twice about submitting invalid reviews? Will that lead to more policing by Goodreads or publishers, or possible reports from other Goodreads users to note if someone seems to be abusing the pre-release ratings function?

Final note: While the source is required before sharing a rating, users can still post review content without the extra step. So, for those dying to say… OMG this is my favorite author and everything they write is amazing and this book will be too — they still can! They just can’t tack 5 stars onto the gushing comments any longer… unless they want to.

Hmmm. Call me skeptical, but after writing all of this, I don’t see this new approach actually making a difference.

What do you think? Will this new approach improve the Goodreads rating accuracy? Or is this just a band-aid for a problem that can’t be solved, other than by blocking any ratings until a book actually comes out?

Spell the Month in Books: December

Spell the Month in Books is a monthly meme hosted by Jana at Reviews from the Stacks. To participate, find a book title that starts with each letter in the month’s name, make a list, share your link, and that’s it! You can share anytime by the end of the month. Some months have additional themes, but feel free to participate however you’d like!

This month’s theme is Giftable: Books you would give or like to receive as a gift. Let’s see what I can come up with…

Here are my DECEMBER books:


D:

Dear Lord Akeldama by Gail Carriger:

A terrific gift for fans of the author’s Parasol-verse books.

E:

Every Summer After by Carley Fortune

I love this author’s books, and this special edition of her first novel is gorgeous!

C:

Clanlands by
Sam Heughan and Graham McTavish

Perfect for Outlander fans — need I say more?

E:

Everything On It by Shel Silverstein

Shel Silverstein books are always great gifts… and I’d argue that they make great gifts for all ages, not just children!

M:

Mythos by Stephen Fry

A big, coffee table-sized book with beautiful illustrations — a terrific accompaniment for the Mythos audiobook (which I highly recommend).

B:

Bookshops & Bonedust by Travis Baldree

Cozy fantasy is never a bad gift option, and the bookshop setting is a plus!

E:

Every Heart a Doorway by Seanan McGuire

I love this series, and the first book is wonderful. It would make a great gift for someone who loves fantasy worlds and portal fiction.

R:

Robots vs. Fairies edited by Dominik Parisien & Navah Wolfe

Sci-fi? Fantasy? Why choose just one! I’m including this books as a really fun pick for gift giving — it’s a terrific collection of short stories, and I don’t think it’s widely known, so it should be new to whoever you give it to!



Wishing everyone a very happy December! If you spelled the month in books, please leave me a link to your post — I’d love to see it!

Discussion: Should bloggers do research before posting book reviews?

A question came up for me this week: Should book bloggers do research before posting reviews?

What got me thinking about this topic was a comment I received on a book review I posted several weeks ago. I didn’t love the book, and explained why.

In the review, I stated that the book is apparently a stand-alone. A commenter informed me that they found my statement confusing, because the author had stated in interviews that this book was intended to have follow-ups involving some of the supporting characters. Additionally, I mentioned some elements of the setting and world-building that I found odd or muddled. The commenter again referred to author interviews, which explain why she chose to include some of the elements that I found out of place, and also mentioned that some of this was addressed in the author’s notes at the end of the book.

Note: Because I’d read the book via audiobook, I did not have access to the author’s notes — which is a pet peeve of mine when it comes to audiobooks, but that’s a topic for another day!

All this is fine. I appreciate hearing more information and getting other perspectives, and it was good to know that this author’s fans seem to enjoy the book more than I did.

What puzzles me, though, is the implication that I should have known these pieces of information prior to posting a review. This raises a few questions for me:

Do book bloggers have an obligation — to the author or to other readers — to track down answers to questions, Google facts about their books, check out author posts, etc before sharing a review, especially one that might not be 4- or 5-stars? Essentially, is it a reasonable expectation that bloggers do more than “just” read the book before posting a review?

In the case of this particular book, it was by an author I’d read before, but not recently. I thought it sounded interesting, so I grabbed the audiobook when it became available. This isn’t an author I follow on social media or elsewhere.

Before writing my review, I checked out the available information on Goodreads. There was no indication that this is part of a series. I looked at the book’s description on retail sites. Again, nothing to indicate that this is anything but a standalone. Without going out looking for more information, all I could go by was what was in front of me — and to me, that appeared to indicate that this book was a stand-alone.

Could I have learned more if I’d searched for interviews and profiles of the author, or checked out their social feeds? Sure. But should these additional steps be an obligation before writing a review? I think not.

My stance is that the reading experience should speak for itself. Sure, it’s fun to follow authors and dig deeper, especially when it comes to our favorites — to understand inspiration, to learn about what might be next, to get more details on the plot and characters, to get insight into intention, writing process, and more.

But also — that shouldn’t be necessary in order to share my feelings about a book. As a casual reviewer, I see my book reviews as expressions of my reactions and thoughts. I don’t pretend to be a journalist or a literary critic! I certainly don’t claim to have any expertise in regard to any particular book, beyond being an avid reader. In general, my reviews are simply my way of sharing my responses to books I’ve read. And with that approach, a deeper dive isn’t always needed.

What I like to focus on is how I felt while reading: Was I interested? Emotionally invested? Compelled to keep going? Or perhaps, confused or bored, or not blown away? Did the book itself make me want to know more about its subject or author? Or was I content to finish the book, whether I loved it or not, and then put it away?

Personally, I don’t feel obligated to look at media coverage or author reviews before posting a review. I share reviews to express my reactions to the books I read. Sometimes I’ll dig deeper or go looking for more information, especially if a book blows me away or sparks my interest in a new or unusual topic — but more often, I write my reviews based on the actual book content, and nothing else. This may not be everyone’s approach, but it works for me.

What do you think? Do you feel obligated to go beyond the book before writing a review? Why or why not?

Please share your thoughts!