Title: The Berry Pickers
Author: Amanda Peters
Publisher: Penguin
Publication date: April 4, 2023
Length: 295 pages
Genre: Historical fiction
Source: Purchased
Rating:
One family’s deepest pain. Another family’s darkest secret.
On a hot day in 1960s Maine, six-year-old Joe watches his little sister Ruthie, sitting on her favourite rock at the edge of the blueberry fields, while their family, Mi’kmaq people from Nova Scotia, pick fruit. That afternoon, Ruthie vanishes without a trace. As the last person to see her, Joe will be forever haunted by grief, guilt, and the agony of imagining how his life could have been.
In an affluent suburb nearby, Norma is growing up as the only child of unhappy parents. She is smart, precocious, and bursting with questions she isn’t allowed to ask – questions about her missing baby photos; questions about her dark skin; questions about the strange, vivid dreams of campfires and warm embraces that return night after night. Norma senses there are things her parents aren’t telling her, but it will take decades to unravel the secrets they have kept buried since she was a little girl.
The Berry Pickers is an exquisitely moving story of unrelenting hope, unwavering love, and the power of family – even in the face of grief and betrayal.
Once again, I have my book group to thank for leading me to The Berry Pickers, a moving story about family secrets, loss, and a search for truth.
On an ordinary summer day in Maine, four-year-old Ruthie disappears as her family picks berries in the nearby fields. Ruthie’s brother Joe, age six, is the last to see her, sitting on a rock finishing a sandwich while he runs off to chase birds. Both will be forever changed by that day.
Joe is haunted by the guilt he carries, feeling that if only he hadn’t left his sister in that moment, tragedy could have been avoided. Their family — mother and father, older sister and two brothers — search tirelessly for Ruthie, but they’re also obligated to the owner of the berry fields where they work each summer. Eventually, they must continue their work, and at the end of the summer, they head back to their home in Nova Scotia with deep holes in their hearts.
Meanwhile, in alternating chapters, we hear from Norma. As a young girl, raised in a practically silent house by a distant father and an overprotective, mentally fragile mother, Norma has been told that the images that come to her of a different mother and a family around a campfire are just dreams. As she grows up, she accepts this version of reality, although she continues to record these dreams in her journals, but she remains skeptical of some of the answers her parents provide when she asks questions. Why is her skin so much browner than theirs? Because she had an Italian great-grandfather. Why are there no baby pictures of her? Because they lost everything in a fire when she was little.
We understand right away that Norma is Ruthie — this isn’t a spoiler! — but it takes much of the book to unravel how Norma ended up where she is. Meanwhile, through their separate narratives, we see Joe and Norma’s lives unfold, and how deeply both are affected by the pain of Ruthie’s loss and everything that followed.
The Berry Pickers is a beautifully written and deeply affecting book. The tragedy that befalls Joe and Ruthie’s family is terrible, but so is the lack of support and resources available in the immediate aftermath. A Mi’kmaq family who come to Maine each summer for farmwork in the berry fields, they’re dismissed by the local police who provide only cursory help. The farm owner too offers lip-service sympathy before reminding them to get back to work. Again and again, we see how the local community and law enforcement see them as other and not worth much effort, and even to blame for the tragedies that come their way, including a terrible incident years later. Joe ends up spending much of his adult life alone, carrying heavy burdens of rage and guilt, and while we may question his decisions, we can understand why he feels he is doing what is necessary.
Norma’s life is easier, on the surface. She grows up in a financially secure home, gets a good education, pursues an academic career — but she’s always adrift, always carrying the weight of her mother’s fears and manipulations, and the overwhelming sense of sadness that pervades their home. Norma’s Aunt June provides love, support, and kindness, but is also complicit in the big lies at the heart of Norma’s family.
We spend much of The Berry Pickers waiting to see how Joe and Norma’s stories will eventually intersect. It’s worth the wait. The ways in which their lives parallel one another, include a significant near miss, make this story especially heart-wrenching. Joe is a flawed man with deep regrets, but we can’t help love him anyway and wish that he could forgive himself much sooner. Norma’s life is driven by the secrets and lies that have surrounded her since her earliest days. The burden she bears leads her to a lonely life, and we ache for her as she suffer her own losses.
The Berry Pickers presents each character’s story with grace and empathy. While this is a story with deep wounds at its heart, the storytelling doesn’t feel oppressively heavy. By using Joe and Norma’s voices, we’re taken along with them through their lives, experiencing their ups and downs, and coming to know each of them in a meaningful way. There are funny and joyful moments too, and the payoff for this journey provides a beautiful ending.
The Berry Pickers is a powerful book that shouldn’t be missed. Highly recommended!
Purchase links: Amazon – Audible audiobook – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.
Bookshelf Fantasies 