Book Review: Murder at Haven’s Rock (Haven’s Rock, #1) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: Murder at Haven’s Rock
Series: Haven’s Rock, #1
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 21, 2023
Length: 340 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong’s Rockton Novels had one of the most unique towns in crime fiction. Murder at Haven’s Rock is a spinoff, a fresh start… with a few new dangers that threaten everything before it even begins.

Haven’s Rock, Yukon. Population: 0

Deep in the Yukon wilderness, a town is being built. A place for people to disappear, a fresh start from a life on the run. Haven’s Rock isn’t the first town of this kind, something detective Casey Duncan and her husband, Sheriff Eric Dalton, know first hand. They met in the original town of Rockton. But greed and deception led the couple to financing a new refuge for those in need. This time around, they get to decide which applicants are approved for residency.

There’s only one rule in Haven’s Rock: stay out of the forest. When two of the town’s construction crew members break it and go missing, Casey and Eric are called in ahead of schedule to track them down. When a body is discovered, well hidden with evidence of foul play, Casey and Eric must find out what happened to the dead woman, and locate the still missing man. The woman stumbled upon something she wasn’t supposed to see, and the longer Casey and Eric don’t know what happened, the more danger everyone is in.

What do you do when you reach the end of a terrific series? If you’re author Kelley Armstrong, you spin off into a new (equally terrific) series! The Rockton series wrapped up in 2022 after seven strong novels, and was then followed by a novella (Dead Letter Days) that serves as a bridge between Rockton and Haven’s Rock.

And here we are, with a new town and new series to explore! The Haven’s Rock series starts with a bang (or kind of a crash and a thud, if we’re being literal) with the first book, Murder at Haven’s Rock.

A quick “history” lesson to set the stage: Rockton was a secret town hidden in the Yukon wilderness, a place where those needing sanctuary could live off the grid for a couple of years. Rockton’s day-to- day needs were overseen by Sheriff Eric Dalton and his partner/lover/wife Detective Casey Butler. The town functioned, but not always smoothly, while the powerful, remote council that controlled the town’s funds made shady decisions about who to allow in, leaving the town to deal with fallout from a variety of criminals and generally bad eggs who also found shelter in Rockton.

The Rockton series ends with the dismantling of the town. Eric, Casey, and a small group of close allies move forward with establishing a new, better version of Rockton: Haven’s Rock, where the town will be built to their specification, and where they’ll have better control over ensuring that only those who truly need refuge are allowed in.

As Murder at Haven’s Rock opens, the new town is still in the final stages of construction, with move-in dates quickly approaching. Eric and Casey make their first visit to Haven’s Rock when the construction project manager requests help. Two of her crew — the head architect and engineer — have gone missing. Venturing into the forest is forbidden, but it appears that that’s where they both went… and then disappeared. Eric and Casey are delighted to get a first look at their new town — although they would have preferred that it not come with missing persons, dead bodies, and potentially multiple crimes to solve.

The mysteries in Murder at Haven’s Rock are doozies. First, it’s not clear that crimes have even occurred, and even if they have, under whose jurisdiction they’d fall. Once Eric and Casey start investigating, they find dead ends and conflicting trails, possible motives, and unwelcome surprises in the shape of outsiders in what they’d believed to be an unpopulated area.

The crime and mystery aspects of this story are superb, with twists and confusion around every corner. The who’s-who of suspects and victims and interpersonal connections is complicated, and the author does an amazing job of keeping it all manageable, even when it seems like there are almost too many options at play. There’s a really satisfying and convincing resolution, even while the ending of the story introduces what’s sure to be a major source of danger and conflict as the series moves forward.

Meanwhile, we get an excellent introduction to the new town of Haven’s Rock. It’s really fun to go alongside Eric and Casey as they explore their new home, especially when their key people start to arrive as well.

Murder at Haven’s Rock is a terrific kick-off to this new series, and I’m delighted to be digging in. As of this moment, two more book are available, with another set for release in February 2026. And even though I have a ton of other reading commitments, I can’t help but admit that I won’t be able to hold off for very long before picking up book #2, The Boy Who Cried Bear.

Interested in the worlds of Rockton and Haven’s Rock? Check out my reviews of these previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)
Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4)
Alone in the Wild (Rockton, #5)
A Stranger in Town (Rockton, #6)
The Deepest of Secrets (Rockton, #7)
Dead Letter Days (Rockton, #7.5)

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: The Ivy Tree by Mary Stewart

Title: The Ivy Tree
Author: Mary Stewart
Publisher: Hodder & Stoughton
Publication date: 1961
Length: 391 pages
Genre: Suspense/thriller
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Mary Grey had come from Canada to the land of her forebears: Northumberland. As she savored the ordered, spare beauty of England’s northern fells, the silence was shattered by the shout of a single name: “Annabel!” And there stood one of the angriest, most threatening young men Mary had ever seen. His name was Connor Winslow, and Mary quickly discovered that he thought she was his cousin—a girl supposedly dead these past eight years. Alive, she would be heiress to an inheritance Connor was determined to have for himself. This remarkably atmospheric novel is one of bestselling-author Mary Stewart’s richest, most tantalizing, and most surprising efforts, proving her a rare master of the genre.

A slightly different synopsis for another edition of the book:

An English June in the Roman Wall countryside; the ruin of a beautiful old house standing cheek-by-jowl with the solid, sunlit prosperity of the manor farm – a lovely place, and a rich inheritance for one of the two remaining Winslow heirs. There had been a third, but Annabel Winslow had died four years ago – so when a young woman calling herself Annabel Winslow comes ‘home’ to Whitescar, Con Winslow and his half-sister Lisa must find out whether she really is who she says she is.

The Ivy Tree opens with gorgeous scenery: A woman enjoys the peace of a pastoral view in Northumberland, savoring the quiet and solitude. But a man shows up and immediately begins yelling at her. He thinks she’s his presumed-dead cousin Annabel, who disappeared eight years earlier. With their grandfather ill and nearing death, her reappearance can’t be coincidence. Connor and his half-sister Lisa have been tending the estate for the old man all these years; it should be theirs. With Annabel’s return, Connor’s inheritance is very much on the line.

But there’s a catch. This woman isn’t Annabel. Although she bears a remarkable resemblance to Annabel, she introduces herself as Mary, a descendant of another line of the family which emigrated to Canada a few generations back. Mary has heard stories of Northumberland all her life, and has come seeking a fresh start.

Almost immediately, Connor proposes a plan. He and Lisa can teach Mary all about Annabel — and if she’ll impersonate her for a brief time, just long enough to convince their grandfather, they’ll make it worth her while. Connor fears that the grandfather has never believed that Annabel truly died, and worries that he’ll leave his fortune to her anyway. With a stand-in, that fear can be addressed. If their scam works, and even if Con himself is left out of the will, “Annabel”‘s inheritance will go to Connor, and fake-Annabel will get a hefty payout for her efforts.

It’s a marvelously twisty scheme, and Mary — who has little money and no real plans — agrees to go along with it. After all, the real Annabel is dead. Who would be hurt by this? After three weeks of intense training, the plan is put into motion, and Mary — now going only by Annabel — arrives at the Whitescar estate to fulfill her role as the returning prodigal.

Annabel’s impersonation is successful with the grandfather, household staff, and visiting younger cousin Julie. But Annabel herself is wracked by guilt and worries as she ingratiates herself into life at Whitescar. Can she succeed, and should she? What does Connor stand to gain? What will this mean for Julie. And what really happened on the night that the original Annabel ran away and left Whitescar behind?

The Ivy Tree is a wonderful example of 1960s-era romantic suspense, verging on the gothic. The old estate makes for a picturesque, lush setting, even while the neighboring estate, Forrest Lodge, lends an air of haunting decay, with the manor house in ruins after a devastating fire years earlier, and an overgrown old tree wrapped in ivy holding up the remaining walls.

For a 21st century reader, this book has an old-school feel to it. The pacing, descriptions, and narrative approach feel very much like throw-backs — which, of course, they are. The Ivy Tree is a great example of its genre and era. There’s an undercurrent of desperation and hidden desires and dire motives. It’s all quite grand and dramatic, but never too over the top.

While the plot moves forward at a mostly fast clip, the author also provides breaks in the action fairly regularly to set the scene. Descriptions of overgrown forests or a centuries-old quarry or even the condition of the roads all add to the overall atmosphere of the book, firmly grounding the characters in their environments and making clear where the beauty and the threats are to be found. A final set-piece involving a mad dash through a terrible storm adds to the overall gothic effect, and is both exciting and chilling.

I loved all the dramatic confrontations, the subterfuges and hidden (and revealed) identities, and the conflicting needs and thwarted ambitions of the various characters. It all adds up to a delightfully suspenseful reading experience. For me, The Ivy Tree feels like an excellent introduction to Mary Stewart’s books.

As far as I can recall, my mother and aunt — two avid readers! — were both fans of this author, and I’m quite sure that at least a few Mary Stewart books were on the shelves of my childhood home. Perhaps that’s another reason why I feel drawn to her novels and want to read more!

Question: Do you have a favorite Mary Stewart book to recommend?

About the author:

Mary, Lady Stewart (born Mary Florence Elinor Rainbow; 17 September 1916 – 9 May 2014) was a British novelist who developed the romantic mystery genre, featuring smart, adventurous heroines who could hold their own in dangerous situations. She also wrote children’s books and poetry, but may be best known for her Merlin series, which straddles the boundary between the historical novel and fantasy.

Her obituary from The Guardian offers a great deal of insight into Mary Stewart’s life and writing career. In addition to the Merlin books (The Crystal Cave and four others), her well-known mysteries include Touch Not the Cat, Madam, Will You Talk?, Nine Coaches Waiting, and many more.

Purchase linksAmazon – Audible audiobook – Bookshop.orgLibro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Novella Review: Dead Letter Days (Rockton, #7.5; Haven’s Rock, #0.5) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: Dead Letter Days
Series: Rockton, #7.5; Haven’s Rock, #0.5
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: St. Martin’s Press
Publication date: February 20, 2023
Length: 87 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Eric Dalton spent most of his life in Rockton, a hidden town in the Yukon for people who need to disappear. Now that sanctuary is gone, and he’s holed up in a wilderness lodge with his girlfriend, Casey Duncan, and their friends, as they scout for a place to build their own Rockton. When Eric and Casey find a literal message-in-a-bottle, it leads them to the mystery of a woman who went missing decades ago, having never received that vital message. As they investigate that cold case, Dalton must finally lay to rest the ghosts of his own past and make some overdue decisions before he’s ready to step forward in his new life with Casey.

Strictly for Rockton series readers, this tidy novella provide an engaging bridge between the completed series and the spin-off Haven’s Rock series. We’re treated to familiar characters in a new, transitional setting, as they prepare to move to a new town and start fresh, on their own terms.

In other words… if you haven’t read the Rockton books, this novella is not for you! BUT… it’s an excellent series, so consider this my friendly encouragement to go pick up book #1, City of the Lost!

In Dead Letter Days, the plot revolves around two sets of communications, rediscovered years after they were written. The first involves a mystery of a missing woman, which Casey feels compelled to investigate. The second hits much closer to home, as letters related to Eric’s childhood come to light and provide him with much needed explanations and an unexpected opportunity for closure.

The Rockton books are all told from Casey’s point of view, so it’s a treat here in Dead Letter Days to have Eric as the narrator. It’s our first time getting to see the world through his eyes, and it’s fascinating.

As I’ve said, this is absolutely not a stand-alone or an entry point — but it is a terrific read that fans should not miss!

As for me, I’m dying to dive right into the Haven’s Rock series… but I’m going to show just a tiny bit of restraint and hold off until the new year.

Interested in the Rockton series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)
Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4)
Alone in the Wild (Rockton, #5)
A Stranger in Town (Rockton, #6)
The Deepest of Secrets (Rockton, #7)

Book Review: The Deepest of Secrets (Rockton, #7) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: The Deepest of Secrets
Series: Rockton, #7
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 15, 2022
Length: 341 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 5 out of 5.

#1 New York Times bestseller Kelley Armstrong returns to the captivating town of Rockton in The Deepest of Secrets, the next installment in one of the most imaginative crime series on shelves today.

It’s not always easy to live in the hidden town of Rockton, something Detective Casey Duncan knows firsthand. Tucked away in the Yukon wilderness, the community survives—and thrives—because the residents’ many secrets stay just that—secret.

But what happens when these secrets start to come out? Overnight, no one is safe. It’s not a question of if your secret will come out—but when.

Casey and her boyfriend, Sheriff Eric Dalton, need to find the culprit while protecting those who have been thrust into the spotlight. For a place built on privacy and new beginnings, Rockton isn’t handling these revelations very well. People are turning on one another, and when one of the loudest complainers turns up barely alive, it’s clear that their trickster is actually a murderer.

The threat of exposure is reaching its breaking point, and no one knows what’s going to happen next.

And so, I reach the end of the Rockton series! I’ve loved it right from the start, and this 7th book ties the overarching story lines together while also providing a fresh new mystery to explore. It also neatly sets the stage for the author’s spin-off series, Haven’s Rock, which I’m so looking forward to reading in 2026!

As with my previous Rockton reviews, I’ll share a quick recap of the series premise:

Rockton is a secret hidden town in the Yukon wilderness, a haven for those seeking extreme shelter from dangers in their real lives — or those who’ve committed some sort of wrongdoing and need a place to start over. Rockton, population 200, is filled with an uneasy mix of crime victims and white-collar criminals — although as Sheriff Eric Dalton and Detective Casey Butler come to discover, the town council is willing to defy its own rules for a price and allow more dangerous people to take advantage of Rockton’s protection.

As The Deepest of Secrets opens, Casey and Eric and their closest friends are well aware that Rockton’s days are numbered. The powerful council, which funds the town, funnels new residents into Rockton, and approves or disapproves current residents’ extensions, is clearly on the path to shutting the entire thing down. As they wait for an official announcement, something occurs to disturb the calm — a sign is posted that exposes one very trusted resident’s secret past. Suddenly, there’s an uproar. People want this person expelled, but are also fearful about their own secrets coming to light.

As Casey investigates to determine the source, and whether other secrets are about to be exposed, blackmail and murder soon follow. And once the council makes Rockton’s imminent closure official, panic and mistrust become rampant. Casey and Eric race against the clock to find the person or people behind these newest crimes, while also being tasked with scheduling the evacuation of Rockton and then dismantling the entire town

Without going into further detail, I’ll just say that the mystery is handled exceptionally well, as in all of the books in this series. Seven books in, there’s a huge amount of emotional investment in the core characters (well, for me at least), and seeing how the closing of the Rockton era pans out is truly fascinating and powerful. Unexpected dangers and surprise villains add to the tension of the story, and there’s a sense of sadness underneath it all as Casey, Eric, and the others literally take apart everything they’ve built over the years.

I can’t say enough about how excellent this series is as a whole. I’ve loved the unique premise, the characters’ individual journeys, and the relationship-building among so many of them, whether as friends, lovers, or reluctant colleagues. Casey and Eric’s romantic relationship is beautiful, especially seeing their deep trust and the careful way they consider one another’s needs and responses.

I do feel a bit of sadness at seeing the Rockton days end, but it helps to know that there’s another series with these wonderful characters to look forward to!

To truly wrap up my Rockton reading adventure, I’m planning to start this sequel/novella right away, which takes place following The Deepest of Secrets, and (from what I understand) is a sort of bridge to the start of the Haven’s Rock series:

Rockton, #7.5, Dead Letter Days

Interested in this series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)
Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4)
Alone in the Wild (Rockton, #5)
A Stranger in Town (Rockton, #6)

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: A Stranger in Town (Rockton, #6) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: A Stranger in Town
Series: Rockton, #6
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 2, 2021
Length: 359 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

In the next riveting thriller from #1 New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong, the paranoia increases – along with the stakes – as the town of Rockton tries to solve the latest mystery at their door.

Detective Casey Duncan has noticed fewer and fewer residents coming in to the hidden town of Rockton, and no extensions being granted. Her boyfriend, Sheriff Eric Dalton, presumes it’s the natural flux of things, but Casey’s not so sure. It seems like something bigger is happening in the small town they call home.

When an injured hiker stumbles from the woods, someone who seems to have come to the Yukon for a wilderness vacation but instead is now fighting for her life, it’s all hands on deck. What – or who – attacked this woman, and why?

With the woman unconscious, and no leads, Casey and Eric don’t know where the threat is coming from. Plus, the residents of their deeply secretive town are uneasy with this stranger in their midst. Everyone in Rockton wants this mystery solved – and fast.

The Rockton series by Kelley Armstrong has been excellent since the very first book, and it’s a thrill to see the connecting story threads weave together here in the 6th book, leading toward an end point still to come in the 7th and final book in the series. A Stranger in Town builds on everything that’s come before it, provides a mystery of its own to solve, and answers questions that have been percolating since the very beginning.

Once again, a quick recap of the series premise:

Rockton is a secret hidden town in the Yukon wilderness, a haven for those seeking extreme shelter from dangers in their real lives — or those who’ve committed some sort of wrongdoing and need a place to start over. Rockton, population 200, is filled with an uneasy mix of crime victims and white-collar criminals — although as Sheriff Eric Dalton and Detective Casey Butler come to discover, the town council is willing to defy its own rules for a price and allow more dangerous people to take advantage of Rockton’s protection.

A Stranger in Town starts with a frightening discovery. In the forest surrounding Rockton, Casey and Eric stumble across a severely injured hiker. She appears to be a well-provisioned but inexperienced tourist, one of the many who pay to be dropped in the Yukon for a wilderness adventure — and like many before her, finds herself in over her head. But as Casey and Eric quickly discover, this hiker wasn’t injured in a fall or animal attack — she appears to have been gravely wounded by hostiles, the pack of “wild” people, seemingly feral or deranged, who live in the forest and pose a continual threat to Rockton and other settlements. What’s more, the hiker was one of a group of four; her companions’ bodies are found nearby.

The attack highlights yet again how dangerous the hostiles are, to the point where the council — the wealthy advisory board that controls and funds Rockton from afar — are ready to shut everything down and dismantle the town, much to Casey and Eric’s dismay. But Casey has had her suspicions about the hostiles from the very beginning of her time in Rockton, and these new murders, and the council’s reaction, give her even more incentive to finally find the long-hidden answers.

If it sounds like I’m being vague… well, that’s intentional! The plot and mystery and clues are all so intricate that to talk about any in detail would mean spoiling the fun of discovering them for yourselves. What I loved about A Stranger in Town, as with the rest of the series, is seeing how the characters interact in each new situation, how much the relationships among the town residents have evolved, and how astutely Casey sees into the truth of the issues and incidents that complicate their lives.

On top of the excellent mystery and the strength of the depiction of the town’s residents, the relationship between Eric and Casey continues to be a delight. They are two strong, intelligent, complicated people. Their personal baggage can cause difficulty when it comes to their feelings and communications, yet their commitment to one another allows them to view situations, and one another, with honesty and fairness. It’s fascinating to see them work through their inner qualms and self-doubt, and to allow themselves to trust in the strength of their love even in moments of serious danger or conflict.

The plot of A Stranger in Town is terrific, and the book is impossible to put down. The mystery at hand is resolved, and there are startling revelations that go way back into Rockton’s history and explain the present challenges the town faces. This book sets up what’s sure to be a dynamite series finale, and I can’t wait to get to it!

The Rockton series ends with book #7. After that, I plan to dive into the spin-off Haven’s Rock series. Next up for me:

Book #7, The Deepest of Secrets

Interested in this series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)
Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4)
Alone in the Wild (Rockton, #5)

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: Alone in the Wild (Rockton, #5) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: Alone in the Wild
Series: Rockton, #5
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 4, 2020
Length: 369 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

In #1 New York Times bestseller Kelley Armstrong’s latest thriller, the hidden town of Rockton is about to face a challenge none of them saw coming: a baby.

Every season in Rockton seems to bring a new challenge. At least that’s what Detective Casey Duncan has felt since she decided to call this place home. Between all the secretive residents, the sometimes-hostile settlers outside, and the surrounding wilderness, there’s always something to worry about.

While on a much needed camping vacation with her boyfriend, Sheriff Eric Dalton, Casey hears a baby crying in the woods. The sound leads them to a tragic scene: a woman buried under the snow, murdered, a baby still alive in her arms.

A town that doesn’t let anyone in under the age of eighteen, Rockton must take care of its youngest resident yet while solving another murder and finding out where the baby came from – and whether she’s better off where she is.

#1 New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong again delivers an engaging, tense thriller set in perhaps the most interesting town in all of contemporary crime fiction.

I’m completely hooked on the Rockton series by Kelley Armstrong, and waited less than a month after finishing book 4, Watcher in the Woods, before diving back in with the 5th book, Alone in the Wild. Needless to say, book #5 provided yet another immersive, exciting reading experience — I couldn’t put it down!

Once again, a quick recap of the series premise:

Rockton is a secret hidden town in the Yukon wilderness, a haven for those seeking extreme shelter from dangers in their real lives — or those who’ve committed some sort of wrongdoing and need a place to start over. Rockton, population 200, is filled with an uneasy mix of crime victims and white-collar criminals — although as Sheriff Eric Dalton and Detective Casey Butler come to discover, the town council is willing to defy its own rules for a price and allow more dangerous people to take advantage of Rockton’s protection.

Alone in the Wild picks up the story about six months after the events of the previous books. Casey and Eric are taking a much-needed vacation from their policing duties in Rockton, enjoying a couple of nights of camping out in the wild, when Casey hears an unexpected sound: a baby crying. She makes a disturbing discovery: a dead woman cradling a living baby, both buried under the fresh snow. The death is obviously very recent, but there’s no time to investigate — the baby is alive, but barely; Casey and Eric rush the baby back to Rockton for immediate medical care before returning to the corpse to look for clues.

Their primary focus is identifying the baby, a girl who appears to be about a month old. From examining the dead woman, it’s clear that she is not the mother of the child… and it’s also clear that she’s been murdered. While crimes not related to the residents of Rockton are outside Casey and Eric’s jurisdiction, they realize that solving this woman’s murder might lead them to the baby’s family, and their priority is returning her to her rightful parents, if they can be found.

Meanwhile, Casey and Eric become the baby’s de facto foster parents, with the help of the rest of Rockton, raising important questions for them as a couple. Due to serious injuries sustained during a life-changing attack in her teens, Casey doesn’t know whether she’ll ever be able to carry a pregnancy to term. Caring for the baby forces Casey and Eric to discuss whether they could see themselves as parents, and what it might mean for them as a couple. Meanwhile, concerns about whether the baby’s parents are capable of raising her bring up uncomfortable memories from Eric’s own past. The complicated emotions brought on by confronting these issues move Eric and Casey’s relationship forward in important ways.

Of course, the investigation itself is fascinating, as it involves venturing far beyond Rockton’s borders and making contact with settler communities who abide by very different rules, beliefs, and ethical standards. This broadens the world of the series in new and interesting ways, and I’m sure will have important implications in future books.

As always, there are plenty of twists and turns, and every time I thought I had something figured out, I was surprised yet again by how inventive and unpredictable Kelley Armstrong’s mystery writing can be.

With two books left in the series, I’m trying to pace myself rather than rushing straight through. It’s a challenge! My goal is to finish the Rockton books in 2025, then start the spin-off series, Haven’s Rock, in 2026.

Next up in the Rockton series:

Book #6, A Stranger in Town

Interested in this series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)
Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4)

Purchase linksAmazon – AudibleBookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: There Is No Ethan: How Three Women Uncovered America’s Biggest Catfish by Anna Akbari

Title: There is No Ethan: How Three Women Uncovered America’s Biggest Catfish
Author: Anna Akbari
Publisher: Grand Central Publishing
Publication date: June 4, 2024
Length: 304 pages
Genre: Memoir/true crime
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Part memoir, part explosive window into the mind of a catfisher, a thrilling personal account of three women coming face-to-face with an internet predator and teaming up to expose them

In 2011 three successful and highly educated women fell head over heels for the brilliant and charming Ethan Schuman. Unbeknownst to the others, each exchanged countless messages with Ethan, staying up late into the evenings to deepen their connections with this fascinating man. His detailed excuses about broken webcams and complicated international calling plans seemed believable, as did last-minute trip cancellations. After all, why would he lie? Ethan wasn’t after money—he never convinced his marks to shell out thousands of dollars for some imagined crisis. Rather, he ensnared these women in a web of intense emotional intimacy.

After the trio independently began to question inconsistencies in their new flame’s stories, they managed to find one another and uncover a greater deception than they could have ever imagined. As Anna Akbari and the women untangled their catfish’s web, they found other victims and realized that without a proper crime, there was no legal reason for “Ethan” to ever stop.

There is No Ethan catalogues Akbari’s experience as both victim and observer. By looking at the bigger picture—a world where technology mediates our relationships; where words and images are easily manipulated; and where truth, reality, and identity have become slippery terms—Akbari provides an explanation for why these stories matter.

There Is No Ethan is one of the most fascinating and bizarre true crime stories I’ve ever read… especially because, in point of fact, no actual crime (by legal definitions) ever took place. And yet, the violation of ethical standards and the emotional manipulation perpetrated by “Ethan” are truly shocking.

In this memoir, the author recounts her involvement with Ethan Schuman in the early 2010s. She met Ethan on OKCupid, and they formed an instant rapport. Technology was not quite at the stage of FaceTime and Zoom, so communication via chat threads and emails was pretty par for the course. Anna and Ethan began an intense relationship via digital platforms, sharing detailed thoughts, emotions, and vulnerabilities, both ostensibly equally excited to meet in real life — something delayed repeatedly due to Ethan’s high pressure job. When Ethan cancelled again and again each time they had plans, his excuses escalated to a cancer diagnosis and surgery — and how could Anna be so cruel as to hold that against him? But eventually, the red flags indicating manipulation and emotional abuse were too much to ignore, and Anna walked away.

Soon after, she was contacted by another woman through a mutual acquaintance, someone who has a disturbingly similar tale to tell. And before long, the two of them were able to find yet a third woman who’d been involved with Ethan for over two years. For all three, the patterns were starkly similar: Intense, non-stop messaging, elaborate personal stories, harsh criticisms should they step out of line, and excuse after excuse for never actually meeting.

There Is No Ethan lays out the chronology of these women’s experiences with Ethan in a factual, organized manner, with extensive excerpts from the messages and emails exchanged over the course of their individual relationships with Ethan. As outsiders, we readers may ask how no one became suspicious earlier, but from reading the correspondence, it’s clear that Ethan was a master manipulator, having absolutely no shame when it came to concocting excuses and alibis, even going to far as to create a fake sister to vouch for him when one of the women showed signs of stepping out of line.

And yet… Ethan was never held accountable for his actions beyond having his name and true identity outed. Why? Because as far as the author is able to demonstrate, he committed no crimes. He never extorted money from his victims; there’s no identity theft, financial scam, or sexual coercion involved. But — what he did was clearly, absolutely, cruel and wrong.

SPOILER AHEAD: You can easily find out Ethan’s true identity through a Google search, but if you don’t want to know, this is the time to stop reading this review!

As the book title makes clear, there is no Ethan. Ethan Schuman does not exist. The profile pictures and other photos he provided to his various victims were all photos he took from an old acquaintance’s social media accounts. No Ethan Schuman attended the colleges or graduate schools he claimed to have attended, nor worked for Morgan Stanley or the US government as he claimed.

In fact, Ethan Schuman isn’t even a man. As the author and the women she befriends discover, the person behind the Ethan persona is a woman named Emily Slutsky. At the time of their involvement with Emily, she was a medical student — and is now a practicing physician.

Confronted with her lies, deceit, and cruelties, Emily’s responses to the woman range from anger to justification to claims of carrying out a fiction in order to try on other lives. She remains remarkably indifferent to the harm she caused, and despite vowing to stop, continued to engage with other women under the Ethan persona for years to come.

No consequences ever seemed to have caught up with Emily. While the trio of woman contacted Emily’s family, her medical school, and later employers, nothing happened. The author is adamant that the ethical breach embodied by Emily’s manipulations should disqualify her from holding positions of trust with vulnerable patients — but if you Google Emily, you’ll see that she continues to practice as an ob/gyn.

The author, a sociologist, explores issues around identity in a digital age, which is all quite fascinating. Still, the real hook of this compelling non-fiction tale is the detailed way in which Ethan/Emily’s lies and manipulation are spelled out. Emily’s victims are all highly educated professional women, who, perhaps due to the ongoing challenge of forging real connections in the age of online dating, made themselves vulnerable to a man who seemed to prize intellectual and emotional vulnerability over anything else. It’s easy to see how they’d be sucked in, especially given Emily’s relentless stream of messaging, leaving them more sleep-deprived and wrecked emotionally with each passing day.

More than a decade has passed since the author’s involvement with Ethan, and technology has evolved enough since then that a broken webcam or unwillingness to have a live conversation would not be accepted as valid excuses in the way it was then. Still, There Is No Ethan is certainly a cautionary tale about the unimaginable ways someone with shady morals and a lot of creativity can take advantage, even of someone who thinks they’re alert to all the warning signs and have taken all necessary precautions.

There Is No Ethan is fascinating, horrifying, and utterly absorbing. It also left me rather furious — as far as I can tell, Ethan/Emily has yet to face any real consequences for her actions. Highly recommended.

To read more about this bizarre story:
New York Times book review (2024)
New York Observer article (2014)
New York Post article about Emily Slutsky (2024)

Purchase linksAmazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: Watcher in the Woods (Rockton, #4) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: Watcher in the Woods
Series: Rockton, #4
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 5, 2019
Length: 364 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Library
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

In #1 New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong’s latest thriller, the town of Rockton—and her fans—are in for another hair-raising adventure.

The secret town of Rockton has seen some rocky times lately; understandable considering its mix of criminals and victims fleeing society for refuge within its Yukon borders. Casey Duncan, the town’s only detective on a police force of three, has already faced murder, arson and falling in love in less than the year that she’s lived there. Yet even she didn’t think it would be possible for an outsider to find and cause trouble in the town she’s come to call home.

When a US Marshal shows up in town demanding the release of one of the residents, Casey and her boyfriend, Sheriff Dalton, are skeptical. And yet only hours later, the marshal is shot dead and the only visible suspects are the townspeople and her estranged sister, in town for just the weekend. It’s up to Casey to figure out who murdered the marshal, and why they would kill to keep him quiet.

In the chronology of the Rockton books, Watcher in the Woods picks up the story three days (3! Days!) after the events of This Fallen Prey. Had I realized that ahead of time, I might have just read straight through… but regardless, even after just a couple of weeks, reentering the world of Rockton is like diving straight into a roaring river — rocks and rapids ahead!

If you’ve read my reviews for any of the previous books, you’ll know (a) I’m hooked, and (b) the overall premise of the series… but just in case, here’s my standard quickie recap:

Rockton is a secret hidden town in the Yukon wilderness, a haven for those seeking extreme shelter from dangers in their real lives — or those who’ve committed some sort of wrongdoing and need a place to start over. Rockton, population 200, is filled with an uneasy mix of crime victims and white-collar criminals — although as Sheriff Eric Dalton and Detective Casey Butler come to discover, the town council is willing to defy its own rules for a price and allow more dangerous people to take advantage of Rockton’s protection.

As Watcher in the Woods opens, the town is dealing with the fallout from events in book #3, but in Rockton, there’s never a moment without some new catastrophe on the horizon. A stranger shows up, watching the town, and there’s no way that should be possible. Confronted by Eric and Casey, he states that he’s a US Marshall come to detain one of their residents, who’s actually a dangerous criminal. Eric and Casey are immediately skeptical: How do they know he’s a marshall? Why would he come alone? How can they trust anything this man says?

It becomes moot after the Marshall is shot as they bring him back to town, although now they have new problems on their hands. Is there actually a killer hiding out in Rockton? Can they trust anyone? Who is this dead man, and what fresh problems does his death present?

Meanwhile, Casey has convinced her distant, talented neurosurgeon sister to make a stealth visit to Rockton to perform surgery on one of their residents — the town’s lack of a resident physician is one of their more urgent problems — and her presence in town raises all sorts of other issues, both personal and professional for Casey.

There’s plenty of danger, and some beautifully orchestrated mind games, as Casey once again has to figure out whether people she trusts have betrayed her (and why), whether people she thought she knew are really who they say they are, and what to do to maintain peace and safety in a town that never seems to know a moment of either.

Casey and Eric’s relationship continues to be a treat, and I love how each book gives us more backstory for different Rockton residents as well. Some new characters promise to add even more depth to the community going forward, and the ongoing struggle with the anonymous council that controls the town continues to be fraught, and clearly will be something that Casey and Eric will ultimately have to confront.

There are a lot of balls in the air in the story, but the author is a master juggler. The narrative is complex and full of twists, but it all comes together and the story moves forward quite well. Can’t say more without spoilers!

Obviously, I’m loving this series, and recommend it highly! But start at the beginning, of course.

That’s four books down, three to go… and I can’t wait to dive into book #5!

Next up:

Book #5, Alone in the Wild

Interested in this series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3)

Purchase linksAmazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: The Mystery Writer by Sulari Gentill

Title: The Mystery Writer
Author: Sulari Gentill
Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press
Publication date: March 1, 2024
Length: 368 pages
Genre: Thriller
Source: Library
Rating:

Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

A literary thriller about an aspiring writer who meets and falls in love with her literary idol—only to find him murdered the day after she gave him her manuscript to read.

There’s nothing easier to dismiss than a conspiracy theory—until it turns out to be true

When Theodosia Benton abandons her career path as an attorney and shows up on her brother’s doorstep with two suitcases and an unfinished novel, she expects to face a few challenges. Will her brother support her ambition or send her back to finish her degree? What will her parents say when they learn of her decision? Does she even have what it takes to be a successful writer?

What Theo never expects is to be drawn into a hidden literary world in which identity is something that can be lost and remade for the sake of an audience. When her mentor, a highly successful author, is brutally murdered, Theo wants the killer to be found and justice to be served. Then the police begin looking at her brother, Gus, as their prime suspect, and Theo does the unthinkable in order to protect him. But the writer has left a trail, a thread out of the labyrinth in the form of a story. Gus finds that thread and follows it, and in his attempt to save his sister he inadvertently threatens the foundations of the labyrinth itself. To protect the carefully constructed narrative, Theo Benton, and everyone looking for her, will have to die.

The Mystery Writer was my book group’s pick for July, and as with many of our group reads, it’s unlikely that I would have picked this one up on my own. Unfortunately, while many of our book group books end up being surprise hits for me, this one just didn’t quite work, despite some clever hooks and unusual story beats.

Theo Benton, approximately 20 year old, drops out of law school in Australia to show up at her older brother Gus’s home in Kansas. Gus and Theo were both left trust funds by their American grandfather, requiring them to become lawyers in order to inherit. Gus did, and is a partner in a local practice. Theo, however, has realized that she doe not want to become a lawyer; instead, she wants to write. Gus agrees that she can stay with him while she pursues her writing goals.

As she starts writing at the cafe where she’ll soon become a regular, she encounters another writer — an older man whom Theo eventually identifies as successful author Dan Murdoch. Theo and Dan form a friendship, and he takes an interest in her writing, offering her tips and encouragement. Finally, when Theo finishes her manuscript, she gives it to Dan to read. He’s enthusiastic, but declines her request to send it to his high-powered literary agent. And the very next day, Theo discovers that Dan has been murdered.

Theo and Gus become entangled in the unfolding mystery as more murders occur — and the two of them appear to be the connection between all the dead bodies. With the police focusing on them and their lives in danger, Theo takes a drastic step to keep them safe.

That’s about enough plot summary to get the general gist without getting into spoiler territory. The plot revolves around convoluted conspiracy theories, and hinges on Theo making some truly ridiculous decisions. So many elements require a complete suspension of disbelief that it becomes harder and harder as the book progresses to take it seriously in the slightest.

Survivalists and preppers, Australian hippies (“ferals”), crazed fans, sinister secrets of the publishing world… there’s a lot going on, and yet, not much of it makes any sense. Theo’s ability to sit down and pound out a potential bestseller over the course of a few months doesn’t feel credible, and neither is her connection to the writer whom she just happened to stumble across. Her gullibility in dealing with the agency felt like a breaking point for me (as was her brainless decision to give someone the address of the secure location where she was hiding out). If not for the book group commitment, I likely would have quit somewhere in the middle.

Still, I finished the book. The story itself moves quickly and it’s a fast read, so I was able to get through it without too much effort. At some point, I felt invested enough to want to see it through and see how it all wrapped up.

I can’t say that I actually recommend The Mystery Writer. There are some interesting facets to the story, but overall, it’s simply not believable and strains much too hard to make it at all convincing. I just didn’t buy it.

PS — Why did the publisher stick this cover on the book? There are no typewriters involved in this story! Feels like a lazy way to say “hey, this book is about a writer!”

Given my lukewarm to not-so-great reaction to this book, it may seem like a contradiction to say that I’d still like to read more by this author! Having read some interviews and other materials on the writing process for this book, I get what she was trying to do, even if I didn’t especially love it. I’d be willing to try again with another of her books, possibly her upcoming new release, to see if a change of topic works better for me.

Purchase linksAmazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: This Fallen Prey (Rockton, #3) by Kelley Armstrong

Title: This Fallen Prey
Series: Rockton, #3
Author: Kelley Armstrong
Publisher: Minotaur Books
Publication date: February 6, 2018
Length: 359 pages
Genre: Thriller/mystery
Source: Library
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

In This Fallen Prey, the next installment of New York Times bestselling author Kelley Armstrong’s thriller series, Casey Duncan is about to face her toughest job as police detective in Rockton yet. When Casey first arrived at the off-the-grid town, an isolated community built as a haven for people running from their pasts, she had no idea what to expect, with no cell phones, no internet, no mail, and no way of getting in or out without the town council’s approval. She certainly didn’t expect to be the homicide detective on two separate cases or to begin a romantic relationship with her boss. But the very last thing she expected was for the council to drop a dangerous criminal into their midst without a plan to keep him imprisoned and to keep others safe. Of course, Oliver Brady claims he’s being set up. But the longer Brady stays in town, the more things start to go wrong. When evidence comes to light that someone inside Rockton might be working as his accomplice, helping him to escape, Casey races to figure out who exactly Brady is and what crimes he’s truly responsible for committing. In the next page-turning entry in Kelley Armstrong’s gripping series, life in Rockton is about to get even more dangerous.

To say I’m hooked on Kelley Armstrong’s Rockton series might be an understatement. I’m obsessed! These stories build one upon the other, and so far, each leaves me thirsty for more immediately after turning the final page.

This Fallen Prey is the 3rd book in this 7-book series, and it’s a fast-paced, adrenaline-fueled race through danger — and yet, it also gives us time to spend with the characters and in the town that we’ve come to know.

Quick recap (or see links below for my reviews of earlier books): Rockton is a secret hidden town in the Yukon wilderness, a haven for those seeking extreme shelter from dangers in their real lives — or those who’ve committed some sort of wrongdoing and need a place to start over. Rockton, population 200, is filled with an uneasy mix of crime victims and white-collar criminals — although as Sheriff Eric Dalton and Detective Casey Butler come to discover, the town council is willing to defy its own rules for a price and allow more dangerous people to take advantage of Rockton’s protection.

As This Fallen Prey opens, a plane arrives on Rockton’s hidden airstrip, delivering a man named Oliver Brady into the town’s custody. The note accompanying his arrival explains that he’s a serial killer, being sent to Rockton for detention by his wealthy stepfather, who hopes to shield Brady’s mother from the grief of a trial and sentencing. There are all sorts of problems with this, especially (a) Rockton was given no warning of his arrival and (b) the town has no detention facilities except one jail cell, typically used for those needing to sleep off a bar fight for a night. With no preparation yet no way to refuse or send Brady back, Eric and Casey are stuck with a dangerous killer to keep under lock and key.

Complicating matters is Brady’s insistence that he’s innocent, set up by his greedy stepfather who just wants him out of the way in order to grab his share of the family fortune. A further complication is that half the town seem to believe him. Some want to free him, but many others want to lynch him. Eric and Casey need to discover the truth, but when Brady manages to escape into the wilderness surrounding Rockton, they find themselves on a hunt for a man they can’t trust but can’t quite condemn.

As with the previous Rockton books, the danger ratchet up page by page, and the chase through the woods is scary and full of new threats and enemies with each turn of the path. The plot is twisty and misleading and full of contradictions, which all come together by the end with a bang.

This Fallen Prey wraps up the core mystery surrounding Brady, but leaves many more big picture questions hanging — which is probably what makes this series so additive. The main story has a conclusion, but there are several thing that occur that seem like critical new wrinkles in our understanding of how the town works and what the roles of various characters are. I’m desperate to know more!

Meanwhile, Casey and Eric’s relationship continues to be a wonderful centerpiece, as their two wildly different backstories add complications to their already complex work and love lives. I love seeing them navigate their differences, their needs, and their respective roles in the town, while also establishing a loving, respectful, supportive commitment to their lives together.

I can’t wait to start the next book in the series — although I’m trying to force myself to take breaks in between and enjoy a bit of the suspense!

Next up:

Book #4, Watcher in the Woods

Interested in this series? Check out my reviews of the previous books:
City of the Lost (Rockton, #1)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton, #2)

Purchase linksAmazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.