If you’ve visited my blog at all during the last few months, you’ve probably seen me gushing over the series of fantasy books by Tamora Pierce that I’ve been listening to obsessively. These three quartets, all set in the kingdom of Tortall, feature brave young women finding their own unique strengths and showing courage under fire as well as compassion to those in need. I loved, loved, loved these books, and vowed to keep going until I’d read EVERYTHING set in Tortall.
That vow still holds, but this post will be a temporary break from the gushy lovefest.
I’ve been following story as well as publishing chronology, so after finishing the outstanding Protector of the Small quartet, my next adventure was to be the Daughter of the Lioness duology, starring Alianne, the 16-year-old daughter of Alanna, Tamora Pierce’s first heroine (and Tortall’s first Lady Knight).
I knew I was in trouble almost immediately. I’ve been listening to the audiobook for all of these series… but within the first few chapters of listening to book #1, Trickster’s Choice, I was hopelessly lost. So much exposition! It felt like I was being bombarded with thousands of names (people, places, historical figures), with no firm grounding in action to help keep track. I made the quick, tactical decision to switch to print, hoping that having the ability to flip back and forth and to refer to the maps and cast of characters listing in the print edition might help. Well… I suppose it helped a bit, but the essence of the story didn’t change, and that became a problem for me.
So what’s it all about?
Here’s the Goodreads summary for Trickster’s Choice:
The Future is in the hands of the next generation.
Aly: a slave with the talents of a master spy, a fabled lineage she must conceal, and the dubious blessing of a trickster god.
Sarai: a passionate, charming teenage noblewoman who, according to prophecy, will bring an end to a cruel dynasty.
Dove: the younger sister of Sarai; she has a calculating mind and hidden depths that have yet to be plumbed.
Nawat: a magical young man with a strangely innocent outlook and an even stranger past; Aly’s one true friend in a world where trust can cost you your life.
Aly is short for Alianne, daughter of Alanna the Lioness and George Cooper, Alanna’s husband and the spymaster of Tortall. Aly has been taught the tricks and secrets of the spy trade since infancy, but at age 16, she’s restless and wants to get out into the field, which her parents oppose. She sneaks out on her own to go boating and promptly gets kidnapped by pirates, who sell her into slavery in the nearby kingdom of the Copper Isles.
The Copper Isles are plagued by centuries of unrest between the ruling luarin (white) nobility and the down-trodden (brown-skinned, native) raka people. Aly becomes a slave in a noble household under suspicion from the reigning monarch. The trickster god Kyprioth, the god of the Copper Isles, enlists Aly in a plan to help raise a rebellion. And the adventure is underway.
I had a very hard time with this book. I was half-bored through most of it. As I mentioned, it’s a lot of people and places, but I didn’t connect with most of the characters. For a story about rebellion, the plot has some seriously slow points. But the chief problem I have with the story is Aly herself. She’s just too skillful and knowledgeable about being a spy. Yes, she comes from an espionage family, but she’s never been an agent or seen active duty. She never falters, never lacks the ability to carry out her ideas, and pretty much never screws up.
One of the things that makes the other Tortall quartets so special is seeing the main characters evolve from young, untrained youths who work and fight to fulfill their potential. Here in Trickster’s Choice, Aly already is who she is. There’s no learning curve, no doubt, and very little introspection.
And that’s not even addressing the social issues that are so problematic, which are talked about quite a bit in the many reviews to be found on Goodreads. Basically, this white, privileged girl from noble background has to swoop in to lead the native people to an uprising, which they apparently couldn’t manage without her. On top of which, when given the chance at freedom, Aly chooses to maintain her enslaved status in order to provide better cover for her mission from Kyprioth, which seems to imply that being enslaved maybe has a purpose. All of this made me very uncomfortable.
Oh, and the love interest is a crow who’s turned himself into a man and is learning to be human. Awkward.
I finished this book with a great sense of frustration and discontent… so why did I continue? Yes, despite my fairly unhappy time reading Trickster’s Choice, I went straight on to Trickster’s Queen, hoping for a stronger second act in the Daughter of the Lioness story.
In Trickster’s Queen:
The stage is set for revolution…
Aly: no longer just a master spy, but a master of spies. Can she balance her passion for justice and her compassion for others, and at what cost?
Sarai: beautiful, dramatic, and rash – will she fulfill the role chosen for her by destiny?
Dove: she has always stood in Sarai’s shadow. Can she prove to the world that she herself is a force to be reckoned with?
Nawat: half crow, half man. He wants Aly for his life mate, but will the revolution make that impossible as they step into new roles to change the future?
Suddenly, Aly is a spymaster. She pulls the strings and directs her pack of spies and their recruits, teaching spycraft and strategy, plotting with the raka rebellion leaders, and instigating high-stakes sabotage throughout the kingdom in an effort to undermine and destabilize the ruling monarchs.
And my frustration continues. How does Aly possibly have the skills to do all this? It makes no sense. And if I had to see Aly referring to her spies as “my children” or “dear ones” one more time, I was going to smack her.
I won’t go too far into story developments or resolutions. The book is sloooooow for a very long time, basically just a recounting of spy tactics and information gathering, over and over and over, until the actual battle takes place at the very end. Meanwhile, there’s a lot of bloodshed (and I’m not sure how we’re meant to feel about that), the fairly casual murder of children, and a befuddlingly huge number of named characters, when frankly, not every single spy, servant, or noble who shows up in a scene needs a name. It’s all just too much.
Argh. It’s so crushing to go from absolutely amazing books (like Protector of the Small) to such a let-down in the continuation of the overarching story.
I really did come close to quitting quite a few times, but I do want to continue with the Tortall books, and I still have a trilogy, a book of stories, and the 1st book in a new series to go. What if the people or events from the Trickster books end up mattering down the road? Call it bookish FOMO, but I forced myself… unhappily… to finish.
I will be moving on to the Beka Cooper trilogy fairly soon, once the library’s audiobooks become available. And once I get through all of my Tortallian TBR list, I’ll be able to better state whether Aly’s books are skippable. For future readers’ sakes, I hope that they are!
The Daughter of the Lioness duology:
Trickster’s Choice – published 2003
Trickster’s Queen – published 2004
13 thoughts on “Disappointment between the covers: On reading Trickster’s Choice and Trickster’s Queen by Tamora Pierce”
Sorry to hear this didn’t work out. Luckily the others I think make up for it.
Yes, that’s true! I’m hoping these two books are just a glitch, and I’ll end up loving the next set of her books.
Fingers crossed 🙂
Lol, I love Tamora Pierce but I 100% agree with you about these books, I have tried to read them many times, but I always put them down in the middle. However, you should try reading the Circle of Magic Series, I loved those.
Oh, that’s great to hear! It’s funny, my daughter is a huge Tamora Pierce fan and is the reason why I finally gave in and started reading all these books, but she won’t read the Circle of Magic books for some reason. I’ll have to get her to reconsider!
It’s been a long time since I’ve read these books, and I think I was in middle school and discussions of white savior narratives weren’t really a thing I was aware of, so I might find it interesting to reread these sometime.
I hope you do! I think reading them as an adult is really a different experience — but I can see how reading them at middle school age might be really uplifting.
Great re view! Great details 🙂
Sorry to hear this one didn’t work out for you. To be fair I would find those issues you highlighted equally frustrating, what a great review!
I’m half way through Immortals – I’m so happy to know I yet have so many of her books to read – I may give these two a miss though.
I bought the first Becca book whilst visiting Canada a few months ago as they are hard to get in the UK. Looking forward to reading that series as well. Hope it’s enjoyable for you. 😊
I’m so glad you’re enjoying the Immortals. I think you’ll really love the Kel books too!
Oh, that’s too bad for you. It’s frustrating to be so deep into something and be such a devoted fan, and feel let down or redirected (unwillingly!). I think with any creative runs, there are likely some lesser books/albums etc. along the way. I can’t think of a book series for me that fits this idea, but I can definitely name bands I loved in college and afterwards that made a few clunker albums along the way, only to come back and redeem themselves. (U2 for example – Bono is king, but…). Great post!
Oh, for sure, I have some favorite authors who have a dud (or two) amidst all their other fabulous books. These two are particularly frustrating because it’s all one world, and the characters connect and reappear in the different books. I feel like I would have wanted much better books about this particular lead character!