Book Review: A Symphony of Echoes (The Chronicles of St. Mary’s, #2) by Jodi Taylor

Title: A Symphony of Echoes
Series: The Chronicles of St. Mary’s, #2
Author: Jodi Taylor
Publisher: Headline
Publication date: October 22, 2013
Length: 336 pages
Genre: Time travel
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

The second book in the bestselling Chronicles of St Mary’s series which follows a group of tea-soaked disaster magnets as they hurtle their way around History. If you love Jasper Fforde or Ben Aaronovitch, you won’t be able to resist Jodi Taylor.

Wherever the historians go, chaos is sure to follow…

Dispatched to Victorian London to seek out Jack the Ripper, things go badly wrong when he finds the St Mary’s historians first. Stalked through the fog-shrouded streets of Whitechapel, Max is soon running for her life. Again.

And that’s just the start. Max finds herself in a race against time when an old enemy is intent on destroying St Mary’s. An enemy willing, if necessary, to destroy History itself.

From the Hanging Gardens of Nineveh to the murder of Thomas a Becket, via an unscheduled dodo rescue mission, join the historians of St Mary’s as they hurtle around History on more hilarious, hair-raising escapades

I’m so glad that this year finally brought me around to starting The Chronicles of St. Mary’s series, which had been on my TBR for ages. I read the first book in the series, Just One Damned Thing After Another, last month, and couldn’t wait to see what would happen next.

In a nutshell, this series follows the adventures of the historians of St. Mary’s, an institute whose staff “investigate major historical events in contemporary time” which means… they time travel! They can’t change anything that’s already happened, but they can go and observe… and they certainly can die or be wounded in an endless variety of gruesome ways while on their hops into the past.

People sometimes think St Mary’s is just a charmingly eccentric bunch of amiable history nuts. And we are. But make no mistake, St Mary’s has teeth. And when we have to – we bite.

In A Symphony of Echoes, some continuing story arcs develop further, even while our beloved historians find themselves in new (and needless to say, extremely dangerous) situations. From a deadly encounter with Jack the Ripper to interfering in the life of Mary, Queen of Scots, the historians of St. Mary’s are adept at picking history’s wildest hot spots and then inserting themselves right into the center of the action — even when they’re really, truly intended just to be observers.

The whole scene breathed peace and serenity. When you consider our usual setting was some bloody battlefield, or rat-filled slum, or viewing a spectacular but hazardous natural catastrophe, it could have been a lot worse. We were in a garden. What could go wrong?

The blurbs for these books focus on the madcap nature of the stories, and comparisons to Jasper Fforde, among others, might lead a new reader to expect nothing but laughs. Even after seeing how dark parts of the first book were, I was still taken aback by how very dire and awful certain pieces of this story are. Yes, there’s plenty of humor and very clever writing and dialogue… but also, absolutely terrible things happen, leaving scars and then some. Max (Dr Madeleine Maxwell), the main character, is usually upbeat and highly courageous, but she has her inner demons and occasional crippling bouts of self-doubt and pain. While overall maintaining a light outlook, these book contain plenty of darkness too — something readers should keep in mind.

A little quirk of the author’s is to include heavy doses of foreshadowing. Whenever things seem to be going especially well, little statements like these pop up:

The end of my world was here and I never saw it coming.

Each time, I find myself holding my breath, and resenting the fact that no one gets to be calm and happy for more than a page or two!

Still, there’s plenty of fun too, despite the more dire nature of some scenes and outcomes, and the writing is always a delight. I had to chuckle over a Big Bang Theory shout-out:

Despite the Cooper/Hofstadter papers on the subject, no one seems quite sure what would happen […]

… and even sweet, sentimental moments tend to have a uniquely St. Mary’s spin:

So there we were. All set for a romantic reconciliation. I gazed into his eyes. Rainbows blossomed. Bluebirds sang. The music swelled to a crescendo. The bloody fire alarms went off.

A Symphony of Echoes is a terrific sequel to Just One Damned Thing After Another. While new, thorny problems arise — some dealt with, some not — the overarching storyline and major bad guy from the first book continue, and remain unresolved as of the end of this book. I’m looking forward to seeing where the story goes next!

I’ve now read 2 of the 14 published novels in the series… so I do have quite a long way to go, but hope to read at least another one or two before the end of the year.

Up next: Book #3, A Second Chance

Purchase links: Amazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Book Review: Just One Damned Thing After Another (The Chronicles of St. Mary’s, #1) by Jodi Taylor

Title: Just One Damned Thing After Another
Series: The Chronicles of St. Mary’s, #1
Author: Jodi Taylor
Publisher: Headline
Publication date: June 1, 2013
Length: 282 pages
Genre: Time travel
Source: Purchased
Rating:

Rating: 4 out of 5.

They say that History is just one damned thing after another. Welcome to St Mary’s Institute of Historical Research – where damned things happen every day.

When Dr Madeleine ‘Max’ Maxwell is recruited by St Mary’s, she finds their methods to be somewhat unorthodox. They don’t just study the past – they actually visit it, carefully observing historical events as they unfold in real time.

And not dying. This last part is important.

The whole of History now lies before Max and her new colleagues, but, as she will discover, time travel is never straightforward. Because History doesn’t like to be messed with, and danger lurks in every century…

The Chronicles of St. Mary’s series has been on my to-read for years now. Back in January, I committed to finally starting it in 2026… and now I have, and I can’t believe I waited this long!

‘You’re feeling a bit under the weather,’ he said soothingly. ‘I know it’s natural for historians, but try not to dwell so much on the past.’

Book 1, Just One Damned Thing After Another, introduces us to the crazy world of St. Mary’s, a seemingly normal, possibly even boring, institute of historical research. But behind the front doors, something else entirely awaits. Max, a history professor in her late 20s, is recruited by St. Mary’s and learns what they’re really up to: Rather than relying on books and artifacts to understand the past, the St. Mary’s team uses time travel to visit and observe key moments and document their findings.

“… Although the phrase “time travel” is so sci-fi. We don’t do that. Here at St Mary’s we investigate major historical events in contemporary time.”

They can’t change anything while they’re there, but they’re able to report back with incredible new findings to pass along through the more official university channels. Their work is revolutionary, but government and university funders are breathing down their necks, and their continued existence is always a question mark.

Max is outspoken and fierce. After a rigorous training period — which includes everything from hand-to-hand combat to field medicine — she begins going on missions with other historians. And as she sees, these missions really are just one damned thing after another. Things go wrong often, and dramatically. Meanwhile, secrets about her colleagues at St. Mary’s change her understanding of certain situations, and betrayal from within threatens Max and everyone she cares about.

Some descriptions of this series describe it as madcap, hilarious, full of hijinks… and that may be true (and granted, I’ve only read the first book) — but I found that Just One Damned Thing After Another gets quite dark at time too. There are certainly plenty of humorous moments, and the dialogue truly makes me laugh at times. Still, there are some pretty awful things that happen to Max and others, including scenes of death and destruction, emotional collapse, and a couple of terrible moments between Max and people she trusts that are upsetting and heartbreaking.

On the whole, though, the book’s fast pace and sense of adventure keeps things moving and doesn’t force (or allow) readers to dwell for very long on the more painful moments. Meanwhile, there are ancient artifacts and extinct creatures to encounter! Even back at St. Mary’s, the inventors and scientists and researchers keep everyone on their toes (explosions, mainly unplanned, abound).

You can say this about historians, we may be the tea-drenched disaster-magnets of St Mary’s but bloody hell, can we think quickly when we have to.

My small quibble with Just One Damned Thing After Another is that there are just so many characters to keep track of! The book has a “Dramatis Thingummy” section at the beginning, listing and defining over 30 characters — which, yes, is helpful as a reference while reading, but feels really daunting as well. There are some people I never did manage to keep straight — we’ll see how many show up in the next books in the series.

Overall, I really enjoyed Just One Damned Thing After Another. The writing is upbeat and engaging, and even through the darker moments, there’s always another bright spot to look forward to. I came to love Max herself and her close colleagues and allies, thought the approach to time travel and the idea of historians as the ultimate explores were amazing, and can’t wait to see what’s in store for the St. Mary’s crew.

Will I continue this series? Absolutely. As of this moment, there are 14 novels in the series (and a long list of associated short stories), and apparently a 15th book scheduled for release in 2027. With so many books ahead of me, I’m going to try to pace myself — but I do hope to read at least one or two more by the end of this year.

Up next: Book #2, A Symphony of Echoes

Purchase links: Amazon – Bookshop.org – Libro.fm
Disclaimer: When you make a purchase through one of these affiliate links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.